Wednesday, August 4, 2010
TV

Huge

Huge gives the My So-Called Life treatment to a weight-loss camp.

Daniel Walters
Drama at fat camp: not the disaster you're expecting
Drama at fat camp: not the disaster you're expecting
Drama at fat camp: not the disaster you're expecting

Here’s the ugly truth: We find attractive people more attractive than unattractive people. Oh, we try to be enlightened and objective, we try to claw our way above our basest, shallowest instincts. But our most reasoned arguments crumble before the flash of a stunning smile.

Physical appearance — sexy or slobby— burrows deep into our subconscious. We give more weight to weight than personality.

So it’s unsurprising that the media and its critics struggle in making honest, profound statements about appearance. A show like Glee makes overtures (literally) about celebrating the less attractive glee club members, then mocks the uglier, dorkier newspaper geek. Critics tut-tut our media for unrealistic standards of beauty, then slam a movie for imagining that Katherine Heigl — even when drunk — would sleep with Seth Rogen.

So you’d think Huge, a drama about a weight-loss camp, would be a disaster. It’s aimed at tweens, after all. It should be trite, offensive, melodramatic, even a bit exploitive.

But miraculously, it isn’t. In the first episode, one overweight girl comments how she loves staying at a camp full of heavy people — because the playing field is level. That’s crap, of course. There’s just as much hierarchy and infighting as in the “real world” — but at camp, they get to squabble as individuals.

We don’t just get “the overweight girl.” We get the “sarcastic girl” and the “stuck-up girl” and the “nerdy live-action role-playing girl” and the “pretty blonde girl” — all of whom happen to be overweight.

Thank showrunner Winnie Holzman, who used to write My So-Called Life, a show acclaimed as one TV’s best depictions of the angsty high school years.

Unlike, say, Glee, Huge respects its characters. They’re people instead of punch lines or plot fodder. Huge isn’t satisfied with talking points, with “just be happy with who you are,” or “society has too-high standards for beauty“ or “just decide to lose weight.” Those arguments arise, but only from the characters, and only to highlight frustrations.

And as Huge progresses, it becomes less about fat kids at fat camp and more about kids at camp — about their pranks and personalities and romantic crushes.

This is not Big Bang Theory-style mockery or an after-school special. Instead, it’s a teen drama — just not one cast from the Abercrombie catalog.

Huge (ABC Family, Mondays, 9 pm)

TIVO-WORTHY

Rubicon
Grand global conspiracies have not only shot JFK, they’ve made for some awful television shows. Think back to Prison Break, 24 and The X-Files, and how — in the end — their conspiracies made absolutely zero sense. Rubicon is a show centered entirely on a conspiracy. But AMC executives also gave us Mad Men and Breaking Bad. Let’s see if they can break the curse. (AMC, Sundays, 8 pm)

Jersey Shore
Emerging like the swamp thing from a primordial ooze of bronze lotion and hair gel, the cast of Jersey Shore returns in a cloud of abs, alcohol and silicon. And so we watch: to mock, to sneer, to feel superior, all the while unconsciously feeding the beast that is American reality television. You — and those horrible Nielsen families — are Dr. Frankenstein, and Jersey Shore is your monster. (MTV, Thursdays, 9 pm)

Hard Knocks
For some football fans, Madden and pork rinds aren’t enough fuel to satisfy during the NFL offseason. For those, HBO offers Hard Knocks, a series getting behind the scenes in high-def and exploring, this season, the New York Jets. (HBO, Sundays, 10 pm)

Also in Remote Possibilities

The River

River creator Oren Peli compares his horror formula to getting a cavity filled.

Blair Tellers |
Wednesday, February 15,2012
TV

Alcatraz

I’m just as lost as the prisoners in this new J.J. Abrams history mystery.

Lisa Fairbanks-Rossi |
Wednesday, February 8,2012
TV

House of Lies

A show about the people screwing the people who are screwing the rest of us.

Luke Baumgarten |
Wednesday, February 1,2012
TV

Portlandia

Portlandia goes where no sketch comedy has gone before.

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, January 25,2012
TV

Napoleon Dynamite

Fine, buy why now?

Blair Tellers |
Wednesday, January 18,2012

Also By Daniel Walters

The Vindow Viper

Hanging on a string above the streets of Spokane. How much would they have to pay you?

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, September 1,2010

Chamber Cleaning

The new Spokane Valley City Council starts its 2010 term with a boom

Daniel Walters |
Thursday, January 21,2010

Nuts, Bolts and Cover-up

Why a man covered up shoddy work on a bridge near Sandpoint — and how he got caught

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, March 6,2013

Robots and Rate Hikes

A candidate aims for the geek demographic. Plus, Avista wants more.

Nicholas Deshais, Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, May 18,2011

For Your Consideration

Chuck Klosterman sees a therapist. Plus, a Doctor Who box set and Craig Ferguson stand-up

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, October 12,2011


 
 
Close
Close
Close