Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Paying For It

The hodgepodge of desperate budget fixes screams for a grown-up conversation, not the same "government is too big" line.

Ted S. McGregor Jr.
[Photo: Don Hamilton]
[Photo: Don Hamilton]
[Photo: Don Hamilton]

You hear it every campaign season: “Government is just too big.” That’s an old favorite. But it’s odd how you rarely hear anybody say we need to curtail national defense, kill Social Security or defund education — a few of the big-ticket items in government spending. That’s too speciic — and too reality-based — to work for a candidate seeking easy political points.

We’ve got a disconnect between our fantasy of big, bad government and the reality of health services for kids and ire protection and public education and all the other things we’ve decided at one time or another were valuable. In states like Washington, that disconnect has driven initiatives that have curtailed the government’s ability to pay its way; now, with this nasty recession, state budgets are falling off a cliff.

Here in Washington, health care has been cut, along with thousands of state jobs. And if voters decide to end the state’s liquor sales monopoly this fall, the cuts will get worse.

The story is repeated across the nation. In Hawaii, they’ve taken 17 days out of the school year. The California university system raised tuition by 32 percent and cut enrollment by 40,000 seats. Ohio has just killed all mental health funding outside of Medicaid, and in Arizona, 1 million low-income citizens have been cut off Medicaid altogether. Nationally, state employment is down by a quarter of a million jobs since 2008.

With no signs of a turnaround, states will start to try the once unthinkable. California continues to seek ways to empty its prisons. Legalizing — and taxing — marijuana may be coming soon. In Washington, we’ve even slapped a tax on candy.

This hodgepodge of desperate measures screams for a grownup conversation, not the same lazy “government is too big” line. Everything should be on the table — yes, our government must get more efficient, but it’s also true that, relative to other developed nations, our overall tax burden is quite low. And why is it that programs for kids and the poor are always cut irst? The federal mess is a huge part of the picture, too, as out-of-control spending and delusional thinking about tax cuts is hurting states.

It’s a big, hairy mess — for some cynics, maybe that’s what they’ve wanted all along. But for the rest of us, who prefer to live in a dynamic, healthy, modern society and not a Third World country, it’s time to demand that our leaders grow up and start creating solutions.

Ted S. McGregor Jr. is the Editor and Publisher of The Inlander.

Also in Commentary

New Frontiers

While the Old West still feeds the mythology of the region, the New West commands a new paradigm

Michael Dax |
Wednesday, May 22,2013

The Sports Mafia

Publisher's Note

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Wednesday, May 22,2013

The English Way

Justice Scalia finds his rationale for an expansive Second Amendment in Common Law — so why does Great Britain have such strict gun control?

Robert Herold |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

What We Pay For

Publisher's Note

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Keeping America

Announcing a new local effort to inspire today’s students to learn where their country came from

George Nethercutt |
Tuesday, May 7,2013

Also By Ted S. McGregor Jr.

DVD Review

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Wednesday, March 16,2005
Commentary

Reality For Sale

How money creates a new reality in politics.

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Wednesday, September 8,2010

Trail Mix - 06.14.12

Congressional Republicans have decided to give it up for the session.

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Wednesday, June 13,2012
Common Ground

Commons Man

King Cole helped Spokane with a grin and a hope for collective success.

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Wednesday, December 22,2010


Very well said...Ted.....I think, in all honesty, I am one of those who has muttered the mantra of "government is too big". I say that phrase for one simple reason. It is TRUE. The hard reality is that we must institute across the board cuts. That means every single program. Poor children and old adults who struggle...YUP....Every single group of sycophantic beggars must realize that Government is not the solution. You and your efforts...your family...your church...your friends. Creative people can find many solutions without begging the big and morbidly obese government. In my recent run for county commissioner, I talked openly about a 20 percent cut. BOY-o-BOY....the yelps and the "how dare you´s". When someone wants to take a way a spoiled brats candy, that spoiled brat will cry and cry and whine and whine. Then eventually, that spoiled little brat will see the light and know that....every once in a long while, you have to eat broccoli. Not every day is Thanksgiving feast. That is how government has become our new Big Brother in our pathetic Brave New World....As a society, we need to look in the mirror and stopp eating so darn much fast food. Kids need to put down the smart phone and iPhone...and maybe, just maybe, they should listen closely in class and be forced to wear a school uniform.
-
Ah, but the ACLU will scream and wet their collective pants. Everyone will moan and begrudge. The beat goes on as China keeps kickin booty and piling up debt while they increase their military at alarming levels and CNN does not even notice. WAKE UP PEOPLE. (-: Aug 19, 2010 | Reply to this comment

 

Thanks for this editorial. I agree wholeheartedly that government spending should be accounted for and at every turn should be useful. On Meet The Press Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm outlined a great use of government grants - creating businesses that employ local workers with products sold to American companies. That is a great use of federal money.
The fact of the matter is, we need government. And since there are approximately 310 million people in the US at varying life stages, from birth to death, we need culpable, overseeable agencies and institutions to provide for our health, welfare and education. The days of carving a life out of the wilderness on your own are pretty well long gone. And lets be clear - the bootstraps theory was pure-d myth, conjured up as a dime novel. The American Dream is certifiably based upon a cheap fiction. Thanks a lot, Horatio Algier.
I don´t hear about how much Iraq and Afghanistan are costing us any more, but I´m guessing the costs haven´t gone away. But what I hear when the hew and cry about Big Government goes up is not about the cost of making war, but the cost of saving and changing lives.
I think President Obama has a great idea, and maybe the Inlander and other regional weeklies could have contests where people submit their cost-efficiency ideas rather than griping non-specifically about big government. To me that griping is code for "I know my kid needs an education, but I will be damned if I´m going to pay the going rate for it." But I´m biased. I teach.

Aug 23, 2010 | Reply to this comment

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close