Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Race to the Finish

Analyzing the McMorris Rodgers-Romeyn debate. Plus, the latest in Idaho’s 1st District.

Kevin Taylor, Nicholas Deshais
Walt Minnick
Walt Minnick
Walt Minnick

OFF POINT?

Watching last week’s debate between Republican U.S. Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers and her challenger, Democrat Daryl Romeyn, most viewers likely had the same thought. This is depressing.

First, there was the congresswoman saying the stimulus was “a huge missed opportunity to actually address more of that infrastructure need” in Eastern Washington. “Only 7 percent of the stimulus actually went to funding infrastructure,” she said.

Wait a minute. About one-third of Obama’s stimulus went to cutting taxes, the first priority for many Republicans, including, presumably, McMorris Rodgers. Income taxes were slashed by $116 billion, reducing the tax burden for 95 percent of working American families. And she voted against it. Now she says she wanted more of it to go to infrastructure?

Did Romeyn point out this contradiction? Nope. He decided to make some other point, first talking about the North-South Freeway before criticizing McMorris Rodgers’ ability to pass legislation.

Which was Romeyn’s approach for the night: barely staying afloat while totally missing the boat.

Not quite halfway through the debate, Northwest News Network’s Doug Nadvornick (and former Inlander staffer) pressed McMorris Rodgers to be specific on what programs she’d cut to support the balanced budget amendment, which would require $1 trillion to be slashed. “Nibbling around the edges isn’t enough here,” he told her. “Whose ox do you gore?” The Defense Department, Social Security or Medicare?

She replied that she’d roll back federal spending to 2008.

Did Romeyn take her to task for wanting to return to days of George W. Bush? To roll back spending on the war in Afghanistan, which was grossly underfunded when Bush left office? Back to the days of a cratering economy, when the country was on the brink of a new Great Depression?

Nope. He said, “We heard grandiose statements but no details,” then went on to give a statement with no details. “We have a lot of waste in government that’s not being addressed,” he said, answering the same question. “That will be one of my priorities: to find that wasteful dollar and turn it around, bring it here to Eastern Washington to invest in our people, our community, our future. That’s what I’ll be doing when I’m elected to Congress.”  
Romeyn: bringing wasteful dollars to Spokane. (Nicholas Deshais)

MINNICK, LABRADOR ALL TIED UP

With Republicans going all-out to regain control of the House of Representatives, it appears their recent attention to Idaho’s 1st Congressional District is giving a boost to challenger Raul Labrador.

Labrador, a Tea Party-ish candidate who was not the first choice of the GOP, has cut incumbent Democrat Walt Minnick’s lead from 10 points to 3 in the last month. The most recent poll by Mason-Dixon, commissioned by seven newspapers that serve Idaho including the Spokesman-Review, shows Labrador has pulled within the poll’s 5-point margin of error.

In recent weeks, Labrador has also received belated funding from party sources, as well as endorsements from the Tea Party Express, Ross Perot’s grandchildren and former Idaho Gov. (and Secretary of the Interior from 2006-2009) Dirk Kempthorne. (Kevin Taylor)

Also in Briefs

Trouble Holding Liquor

Sorting out Washington's new booze law. Plus, a new judge, and an uninvited sheriff.

Chris Stein, Joe O'Sullivan |
Wednesday, March 7,2012

Seventh in the Nation

Washington's big gay week. Plus, revolution and a challenge.

Chris Stein |
Wednesday, February 15,2012

Engaged to be Married

Washington mulls gay marriage. Plus, Idaho goes back to the drawing board.

Chris Stein, Daniel Walters, Joe O'Sullivan |
Wednesday, January 25,2012

Reform On

The new Spokane City Council is already taking on the police. Plus, WSU heads to Cuba

Inlander Staff |
Wednesday, January 18,2012

PACs Are the Taliban

Roskelley takes on Mielke. Plus, a building crisis, a Supreme Court smackdown and the quest to end corporate statehood.

Inlander Staff |
Wednesday, January 11,2012

Also By Kevin Taylor, Nicholas Deshais

Plague Upon the Locust

If you have cancer and a favorite tree, Chevron will run it through a wood chipper. They’ll even supervise.

Kevin Taylor |
Friday, November 20,2009

Aboard the Ark

Kevin Taylor |
Wednesday, October 1,2008

Get Lit 2011

A handful of the early events in next week's literary festival.

Michael Bowen, Luke Baumgarten, Daniel Walters, Nicholas Deshais |
Wednesday, April 6,2011

Political Mapmaking

Slade Gorton on why his commission is changing the way we vote in Washington state.

Nicholas Deshais |
Wednesday, July 6,2011

Flags for His Brothers

An Idaho man plans an epic journey to honor soldiers killed in Iraq

Kevin Taylor |
Wednesday, April 21,2010


The debate was disappointing and boring. Would be nice to actually see them debate without the stupid little rules. McMorris-Rogers looked lost and disinterested the whole time and never could really defend her record or say what she will do to help Spokane and Eastern Washington in the future. Meanwhile Romeyn seemed to content to stay with what he had written down on his note instead of actually attacking and going after Cathy with her weak responses to anything asked of her. He missed a huge chance, and while he will still get my vote, I wish he was actually a little more forceful pointing out her lack of record and her horrible and contradictory statements.

Also, did anyone see McMorris-Rogers website claiming the won the debate? I guess her campaign didn´t actually have a chance to see her looked like a little lost retarded puppy the whole debate. Oct 29, 2010 | Reply to this comment

 

Cathy has no public speaking skills whatsoever. She´s been a politician her whole life and she can´t perform the most basic political act. What an indictment of the voters of eastern Washngton that they keep electing her. You´ll note that her postion in GOP ´leadership" entails only standing behind Boehner and the other men for photo ops, but never saying a word.

Daryl´s a former weather reader. But despite a decent ability to make the mundane sound dramatic, he can´t liven up this campaign. What he needs is someone with a brain to actually write up some intelligent talking points for him. Nov 01, 2010 | Reply to this comment

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close