Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Sinking Standards

Anthony Weiner — like all cads and cheaters — should resign.

George Nethercutt

With New York Congressman Anthony Weiner now coming clean that he did after all engage in “regrettable behavior,” behavior that he is “truly sorry for,” the rest of us are left with a lingering, upsetting image of Congress. There are too many people we can’t respect, who waste time on destructive personal conduct and lie about it, and are thus distracted from the monumental national and international problems they must solve. Where, we ask, are more people to serve in public office who are statesmanlike, honorable and free of the perversities that we often see in tabloid-like format on nightly news programs?

Anthony Weiner is a pathetic soul. As I watched him sniffle through his news conference, begging for forgiveness for the lewd behavior that he admits with unknown “friends” he met on Facebook, admitting anything and everything that might yet come out and diminish him even further (lewder photos, phone sex, transcripts of salacious conversations, whatever), I was struck by the notion that this guy might even be perversely reveling in his fall from grace. The world’s television cameras and microphones are focused on him, unlike the little focus that he might derive from doing his Congressional business.

I was also struck by how often he emphasized how much he and his wife love each other and how hard he works for the people of his district. In between sniffles, he rightly admitted that he “made repeated mistakes,” his behavior was “disgusting” and he takes “full responsibility” for his actions — but, as I write this, he’s not resigning. That’s what’s called “cheap grace.” Thankfully, his wife of less than one year was spared the indignity of accompanying him to the microphone. It’s sad for her that he continued his regrettable conduct even after they were recently married.

Yet this rather perverted guy won’t resign from office.

There must be something about New York Democrats — Congressman Charlie Rangel comes to mind, and so does former New York Attorney General Elliot Spitzer (the former prostitute patron who now has his own TV show on CNN). These guys admitted to indecent behavior (in Rangel’s case, cheating on taxes and underreporting assets and income), and only Spitzer had the decency to leave politics — but I expect he’ll be back before long, reformed. And now we’re exposed (literally) to Anthony Weiner. Perhaps there’s an explanation for their collective arrogance and their unwillingness to sacrificially act on their professed feelings of shame. Or perhaps prominent people in our society are above shame.

But there’s also the example of former New York Republican Congressman Chris Lee, who correctly resigned office as the press learned of the shirtless photo he sent to a young lady (not his wife). Speaker John Boehner reportedly insisted he resign that day.

It’s a certainty that Weiner’s fight to retain his high office (“I’ve worked very hard for years for my constituents in New York”) is a bad example for young people and other office holders everywhere. The message of Anthony Weiner: You can be a scumbag, and, if you don’t resign, you may survive. If the Democrats are smart, they’ll insist that he step aside soon.

Perhaps I come from the old school that says that if you commit acts involving moral turpitude, you should be decent enough to resign positions of responsibility. Most major companies and public institutions have such clauses — ones that say if you breach high standards, you’re gone. Somewhere along the way, those strict standards have begun to apply less to today’s elected officials.

Perhaps it started with President Bill Clinton, who infamously set a standard that what an elected official does on private time shouldn’t affect his ability to perform public duties. That standard allowed Clinton to survive in office, as it did for Louisiana Republican Senator David Vitter, who admitted having only “conversations” with D.C. prostitutes and was reelected to the Senate. It also worked for conservative South Carolina Republican Governor Mark Sanford, who admitted an extramarital affair and fought successfully to finish his gubernatorial term.

It didn’t work for Nevada Republican Senator John Ensign, though. He resigned from the Senate this year after admitting an extramarital affair with the wife of his office staffer and arranging payments to her; the Justice Department is looking into whether Ensign broke laws in the process.

It’s all very salacious, but it begs another more fundamental question about modern American society. Yes, we’ve always seen immorality and human failings in our public officials, but today these cads and lying cheaters expect that they can tough it out — that the public is forgiving, non-judgmental and understanding of such misdeeds. And if they didn’t break any laws, then they deserve to retain the prestigious office they’re so privileged to hold.

Regrettably, lawbreaking is the new standard — not embarrassing, dishonorable or immoral actions that determine when a course of conduct is so egregious as to require resignation.
But that standard is damaging to public institutions and especially to younger generations of potential office seekers. At a time when America’s problems are nearly overwhelming and extraordinarily complex, our nation needs its best and brightest to focus like lasers on solving those problems. And shouldn’t we expect those in office to be people of honor, clean-living and worthy of the high position they hold?

If they were, perhaps we’d trust their judgments more — and the approval rating for Congress would be above single digits.

George Nethercutt is the former Republican congressman representing Spokane. His column appears here once a month.

Also in Commentary

The English Way

Justice Scalia finds his rationale for an expansive Second Amendment in Common Law — so why does Great Britain have such strict gun control?

Robert Herold |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

What We Pay For

Publisher's Note

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Keeping America

Announcing a new local effort to inspire today’s students to learn where their country came from

George Nethercutt |
Tuesday, May 7,2013

Cougar by the Tail

Publisher's Note

Ted S. McGregor Jr. |
Tuesday, May 7,2013

Power to the People

Will Spokane step up and grab its own future?

Thomas Alan Linzey |
Tuesday, May 7,2013

Also By George Nethercutt

A New Red Menace

National debt is proving to be a formidable adversary.

George Nethercutt |
Wednesday, March 9,2011
Comm

Woman Power

The 2012 election will pit Sarah Palin against Hillary Clinton.

George Nethercutt |
Wednesday, December 8,2010

Sizing up the Crowd

Beating Obama should be a snap, given the right candidate.

George Nethercutt |
Wednesday, May 11,2011

Identity Crisis

We must change the way world thinks about the United States.

George Nethercutt |
Wednesday, November 9,2011

Going Dutch

With its enviable waistlines (and lifespans) Holland's two-wheel culture is something America should emulate.

George Nethercutt |
Wednesday, June 13,2012


Where is the commentary from Mr. Nethercutt on all of the Republicans caught in sexcapades? Why does he choose to single out a democratic congressman, who did not have any physical relationship and has not broken any laws? The answer is that Mr. Nethercutt doesn´t actually care about what is right and wrong. He, like most other conservative right, would like to pretend that when Republicans cheat on their wives it is about the main stream media putting them in the cross hairs, but when democrats get caught in a similar situation, our national security is at risk. Just a couple of examples to jog Mr. Nethercutt´s memory:

Mr. Vitter Senator from LA (R) cheating with hookers but still gets voted back to the Senate.

Newt Gingrich having sex with his third to be wife while his second wife is in the hospital with cance

John Ensin (R) NV having sex with a staffer, who did not want to continue the affair, then trying to buy off her husbands silence with a cash payment that was negotiated by Senator Coburn (R)

The shirtless NY 26th guy

The Appalachian trail to Argentina and Gov. of SC

Rep. Weiner did a stupid thing, and should be voted out in the primary, but for Mr. Nethercutt to forget about his side of the isle is just plain sad, and is representative of his world view- a fairytale where everything Republican is good and everything democratic is bad. Jun 08, 2011 | Reply to this comment

 

Maybe, just maybe, it´s about time we return to the days of yesteryear folks, when what goes on behind closed doors stays there. The sleaze does not go away when it´s uncovered. It simply sets an example for young people to follow that you can behave in any immoral or tasteless manner you choose, and you will just be accepted as one of the crowd. Too many people expect that people in power behave in ways that they themselves are guilty of behaving, and blaming the dirty political games on those in positions of power who they expect to somehow be superhuman and able to resist all temptation.

A family member once told me of her experiences at her big business employer -- subjected to demeaning and hostile comments and phone calls, and even threatening messages that suggested that she was endangering her own life by reporting the problem to human resources. Me? I worked for almost 18 years in business and was never once subjected to that sort of treatment by anyone in the companies for which I worked, with one minor exception when I was very young, which quite easily slid off my back like the proverbial water off a duck.

Recommended reading for Republicans follows:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-13711836 Jun 09, 2011 | Reply to this comment

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close