Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Grading on a Different Curve

With its surprisingly smart script, Bad Teacher is a send-up of typical romantic comedies.

Maryann Johanson
Teacher's being naughty. But the movie she's in is good.
Teacher's being naughty. But the movie she's in is good.
Teacher's being naughty. But the movie she's in is good.
MORE INFO

BAD TEACHER
Rated R
Directed by: Jake Kasdan
Starring: Cameron Diaz, Jason Segel, Justin Timberlake

It doesn’t descend to the level of the so-evil-it’s-genius Bad Santa (which it clearly hopes to invoke with its title alone), but Bad Teacher is a refreshing breath of justso-wrongness in today’s movie milieu. How’s that? The gross-out comedy genre is all about piling degradation onto supposedly sympathetic protagonists, inviting us to laugh at those characters ... until the sharp about-face that invariably occurs in the third act, when suddenly the tone turns sappy and we are expected to care about the fates of the characters we’ve been ridiculing.

But the small wonder of Bad Teacher is that director Jake Kasdan never invites us to feel sorry for Cameron Diaz’s unrepentantly terrible educator. On a good day, she sleeps through class and berates her students; on a bad day ... well, no spoilers. She’s a hilariously awful person. We can laugh at her precisely because we aren’t expected to see her — or her hapless students — as realistic. (Of course, this wouldn’t be funny at all if this were a real school, a real teacher and real students. Our educational system is enough of a disaster.) But Bad Teacher is a live-action cartoon, and Kasdan intends it that way.

So we can chortle at Diaz’s Elizabeth Halsey — who’s her own worst enemy — without worrying about whether we’re supposed to be laughing at her or sympathizing with her. She wants stupid, shallow things, and she does stupid, shallow things in hopes of achieving her stupid, shallow dreams.

When some of its characters attempt to avoid humiliation, Bad Teacher does have its yucky bits. But this movie isn’t trying to out-gross the gross-outs. (Anyone expecting a Judd Apatow-style barrage of disgustingness will be disappointed.) Instead, Bad Teacher is a parody of romantic comedies.

Halsey’s stupid-shallow schemes don’t quite backfire on her just so she’ll be humiliated, and the movie isn’t about allowing us to enjoy watching her be humiliated. It’s about allowing us to see how stupid and shallow the traditional rom-com is.

Halsey wins some of what she wants, and in a crude, barbed way that holds up the traditional rom-com itself for ridicule (which is a good thing indeed). Instead of asking us to see the lovey-dovey, soft-focus, sigh-inducing romance in a woman who chases down the man of her dreams, what we get instead is the cold, hard reality of unromantic game-playing. The joke is on the audience, too: If Elizabeth Halsey is laughable, shouldn’t we see most rom-com heroines the same way?

Screenwriters Gene Stupnitsky and Lee Eisenberg failed miserably with their desperately unfunny “comedy” Year One, but their Bad Teacher script is an unexpectedly smart pleasure. The sneaky success of the film is, however, mostly down to Kasdan, who also made the brilliant Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story. He is rare among today’s American filmmakers in being able to maintain a consistent comedic tone of not-so-dumb crassness. His reward should be a big gold star and extra cookies at snack time.

Also in Screen Feature

In-Alien-able Right

Prometheus explores the back story to a 1979 horror-in-space classic. But does it need to?

Scott Renshaw |
Wednesday, June 6,2012

Bright Little Bloodbath

Headhunters is a hard-boiled Nordic crime thriller with a sweet candy coating.

Luke Baumgarten |
Wednesday, June 6,2012

Grade Expectations

Why we decide what movies we'll enjoy before we even see them.

Scott Renshaw |
Wednesday, May 30,2012

Fairy Tale Fail

Snow White and the Huntsman brings little excitement to a well-worn story.

Maryann Johanson |
Wednesday, May 30,2012

Summer Love

Or summer disappointment? It depends what's playing that week.

Multipe Authors |
Wednesday, May 16,2012

Also By Maryann Johanson

Safe Words

Just say 'action,' 'Statham' and, perhaps for the first time, 'complexity.'

Maryann Johanson |
Wednesday, April 25,2012

Children of the Night

Vampires are sensitive, werewolves are decisive and girls are idiots. Nice message, Twilight.

Maryann Johanson |
Wednesday, June 30,2010

Bump and Daily Grind

Good dancers! Evil dancers! Stanley Tucci! How did such a winning formula go so wrong?

Maryann Johanson |
Wednesday, December 1,2010

Loony Bin

This film about sociopaths should be less schizophrenic

Maryann Johanson |
Tuesday, November 23,2010

Brain Dead

Stallone flexes his action muscles again, but that doesn’t save Bullet to the Head

Maryann Johanson |
Tuesday, February 5,2013


 
 
Close
Close
Close