Wednesday, August 10, 2011

The American Way

Which country star best represents our country’s values?

Seth Sommerfeld

It's a dark time for our country. We’re in so much debt we had to raise a ceiling (making this our worst ceiling-related crisis since 1984, when Rock Master Scott & the Dynamic Three informed us that the roof was, in fact, on fire). NASA’s space shuttle program is kaput. Macho Man Randy Savage is dead.

Times like this call for a kick-start from the most purely American music: country. And in our moment of darkness two of the genre’s champions — Toby Keith and Reba McEntire — come riding into Spokane on their noble steeds (in the shape of posh tour buses — not to ruin the illusion).

With both stars strutting and singing on Spokane stages this week, the question becomes: Which of the two is more likely to help us out of this national abyss? Or to put it more bluntly: Who is more “America”?

Lyrical Patriotism

MUSIC_thumbsup.jpgTOBY: Keith’s no-nonsense patriotism was best summed up in his post-9/11 ode “Courtesy of the Red, White, and Blue (The Angry American)” with the line, “And you’ll be sorry that you messed with the U.S. of A, ’cause we’ll put a boot in your ass, it’s the American way!” You can’t find a more in-your-face kick-ass American song outside of the Team America: World Police theme.

REBA: While McEntire can do a mean rendition of “God Bless America” and her songs are littered with Americana, her tunes tend to avoid the politica

Fulfilling the Capitalist Dream

TOBY: Keith has sold more than 13.5 million albums, which is no small feat except that…
MUSIC_thumbsup.jpg
REBA: … McEntire has sold more than 56 million albums. Well, this one’s no contest.

American Ideals

MUSIC_thumbsup.jpgTOBY: Keith is brash, cocky and had a smash hit with “I Wanna Talk About Me.” Suck on that confidence, France.

REBA: McEntire gives a voice to the strength of the perseverant underdog on hits like “Fancy” and “I’m A Survivor,” but the running theme of betrayal in her catalogue is disconcerting. You don’t cheat on America, America cheats on you.

Acting Chops

TOBY: Keith wrote and starred in Beer for My Horses, a movie based on his hit song of the same name. The film co-stars Ted Nugent as a mute lawman who fights criminals via bow-hunting. It’s the type of film one streams with friends on Netflix hoping to go all Mystery Science Theater 3000 on it, only to go, “You know, that wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought it would be.”

MUSIC_thumbsup.jpgREBA: McEntire is best known for her six-season run as the star of the cable sitcom Reba (a very apt casting, by the way). More importantly, she started her acting career in the 1990 film Tremors, meaning that she has only one degree of separation from Kevin Bacon.

Wild Card!

MUSIC_thumbsup.jpgTOBY: Keith has been a three-time guest on the truthiest and most American of American shows – The Colbert Report. (He’s a four-timer if you count the Christmas special.)

REBA: Reba has often been dubbed “The Queen of Country.” Sorry, sister. In case you haven’t checked a history book, we don’t take kindly to monarchy on this side of the pond.

Final Verdict

By a score of 3-2, Toby Keith and his machismo make him more “America.” And since we all know America is No. 1, by the transitive property, Toby Keith is No. 1.

Reba McEntire plays with Sunny Sweeney • Fri, Aug. 12, at 7 pm • $80-$150 • All-ages • Toby Keith plays with Eric Church • Thurs, Aug. 18, at 7 pm • $80-$150 • All-ages • Northern Quest Casino • 100 N. Hayford Rd., Airway Heights • ticketswest.com • (800) 325-SEAT

Related content

Also in Music Feature

The Cowboy's Cowboy

A Canadian sings about the life —  not just the lifestyle — of the new West

Marty Demarest |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Echoes of the Past

If rootsy Americana is your thing, Pokey LaFarge is making your new favorite songs

Gawain Fadeley |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Band of Brothers

Flying Mammals take experimentation to a whole new level

Sarah Munds |
Tuesday, May 7,2013

You Like Us?

Overnight pop stars MGMT are still surprised at their own success

Jordan Satterfield |
Tuesday, May 7,2013

Dirty Words

Tyler, the Creator scares the hell out of people — and maybe that’s a good thing

Leah Sottile |
Tuesday, April 30,2013

Also By Seth Sommerfeld

Homegrown Hootenanny

Oregon-bred band Larry and His Flask grew a following in living rooms and basements

Seth Sommerfeld |
Wednesday, November 16,2011

The Other Guys

When Billy Corgan comes a-knockin’, side project bands get put on hold

Seth Sommerfeld |
Tuesday, August 21,2012

Robert Smith in Chaps

Murder by Death is inspired by the saddest goth rockers and wide-open countryside.

Seth Sommerfeld |
Wednesday, September 21,2011
CD Review

'White Crosses,' Against Me!

For a band constantly branded as hypocritical, White Crosses feels pretty authetic.

Seth Sommerfeld |
Wednesday, June 23,2010


 
 
Close
Close
Close