Wednesday, December 5, 2012

The Same with Less

How police and firefighters will cope with the coming cutbacks

Joe O'Sullivan
Assistant Fire Chief Brian Schaeffer at Station 9. [Photo: Christian Wilson]
Assistant Fire Chief Brian Schaeffer at Station 9. [Photo: Christian Wilson]
Assistant Fire Chief Brian Schaeffer at Station 9. [Photo: Christian Wilson]

Outside the window of Spokane Fire Chief Bobby Williams’ office, downtown Spokane cuts a jagged skyline into the day. As Williams explains the ins and outs of trying to keep the same levels of service with less, three of his trucks are out right now, dealing with medical emergencies. This is one new reality of firefighting: more medical calls than ever.

There’s another new reality about to take place: Mayor David Condon’s budget, which comes amid his large reorganization of city government and an effort to close a multi-million dollar budget shortfall. Condon is working toward eliminating nearly 100 city positions, most of which are currently unfilled. Bolstered by a conservative City Council majority, even City Council President Ben Stuckart concedes it is likely to pass with few changes when it’s voted on Dec. 10.

Under the mayor’s budget, the fire department will lose 23 positions, about half of which are currently vacant. That leaves the fire department with a little more than 300 workers.

“There’s no way that we can take that kind of reduction without impacting service,” Williams says. “We have really limited options.”

Those options were to close one of Spokane’s 15 fire stations, to take a fire engine out of service or to shift trucks around and partially close Fire Station 9 on the South Hill at 1722 S. Bernard St. Williams chose the third.

What that means is a two-person rescue unit will move into the South Hill station. It can deal with medical calls but won’t be able to fight fires on its own. When a fire breaks out in its territory, it will have to wait for backup from one of the city’s other 14 stations. Williams says other stations can often respond just as quickly to a fire. But if those firefighters are dealing with their own calls or are battling a blaze elsewhere in the city, there might not be immediate backup.

“Is it what we desire to do?” Williams says. “No, our desire is not to have to cut the budget, but that’s not an alternative we have.”

When Condon announced his budget in August, he insisted the 19 eliminated police officer positions wouldn’t hurt the city’s police force because those spots were already vacant. But because it takes so long to train officers, officers who retire or decide to otherwise leave create holes that can’t be quickly replaced. And that’s how new Spokane Police Chief Frank Straub must deal with a situation similar to Williams: doing the same with less.

“It’s not hypothetical, it’s reality,” Straub says of the coming shortage of police in 2013. “We’ll probably go down about five to 10 officers.”

Straub says he’s trying to get an early sense of how many officers will retire in 2013. The new chief is also assessing whether he can free up manpower for the streets by hiring civilians to do administrative work currently handled by officers.

‘There’s Money Available’

Stuckart sits in Atticus one day last week, his back to the counter, pouring San Pellegrino from a can. He spews exasperation about how the four conservative council members voted down a usually routine property tax levy — it would cost about $4.50 per year for most homeowners — that Stuckart hoped could be dedicated to police and fire staff. He believes the conservative bloc is trying to punish the police and firefighter unions.

“They’re already cut to the bone, we’re already behind other cities,” Stuckart says, referring to police and firefighters.

If he had the votes, Stuckart says he’d propose to take $2 million in reserve funds and split it between police and fire to help with staffing next year. In reality, he’s planning to offer some more modest proposals, but he won’t elaborate, saying that if the details were printed the conservative council members would just find excuses in advance to oppose them. Better, he added, to put them on the spot. Regardless, Stuckart doesn’t have much faith.

Williams, the fire chief, reacts pretty cautiously to Stuckart’s hopes of securing stopgap money to prevent staffing cuts. He says he wouldn’t want to hire firefighters “if we’re just trying to patch a short-term window, and I’m going to have to turn around and do the same thing next year.”

Also in News

Local Limits

What stands between your shopping cart and local farmers

Heidi Groover |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Feds Come Knocking

The feds scare a medical pot store from opening up; plus, how to help those displaced by last week’s fire

Heidi Groover, Deanna Pan |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Rats Giggle Too

And that's a bigger deal than you might think

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

There's Not Enough Poverty In Kids' Books

A Whitworth researcher studies how picture books reflect the reality of American poverty

Deanna Pan |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

We Can Turn DNA into Music

An Eastern Washington University professor creates audio interpretations of living things

Seth Sommerfeld |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Also By Joe O'Sullivan

Let’s Get Weird

I have no idea what Holy Motors is about, but I really liked it

Joe O'Sullivan |
Tuesday, November 20,2012

Government, Privatized

Mayor Condon continues to shake up City Hall and outsource certain services. But will it work?

Joe O'Sullivan |
Wednesday, June 6,2012

Bait And Switch

Local agencies jockey for animal control contracts; plus, a new way to fund Public Facilities District projects

Joe O'Sullivan, Chris Stein, Daniel Walters |
Tuesday, July 3,2012

Coal Trains Coming

The Environmental Protection Agency weighs in on coal dust. Plus, a peace protest turns into pandemonium in Colville.

Joe O'Sullivan, Chris Stein |
Wednesday, April 25,2012


Think of all the attorney´s fees and settlement dollars that will be saved as the police force shrinks.

San Pellegrino from a can? How plebeian. Dec 07, 2012 | Reply to this comment

 

We as a country have a pretty broken fire service to begin with. Fire call volumes are down drastically (Spokane is something of an oddity, they seem to have more fires than some cities here in the west), with 90% or more of many large dept.´s run volume being medical related, but we are still spending inordinate sums of money on fire apparatus, and responding to calls like they´re all fires.

Maybe if you clowns managing the outfit wouldn´t send a freakin´ engine to every medical call (to mistreat the AMR workers and do nothing, by the way...talk to the ambulance crews some time, it´s pretty depressing how our ´heroes´ comport themselves), you could save on your fuel and maintenance and not lay off your guys.

You´d be much more benefited to send a lighter QRU. A firefighter or two on an SUV with a jump kit and some basic rescue gear, maybe even a gas monitor. Unless the patient is on fire, there´s no reason to have an engine there. Leave the engineer at the station in case you need to have the engine roll somewhere or run on a fire.


Heck, firemen don´t even LIKE doing EMS. They only do it so they can ride big red and pretend they´re in 1970´s Chicago. Dec 10, 2012 | Reply to this comment

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close