Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Freedom Lovers

Conservatives propose a “Freedom Agenda”

Jacob Jones
State Rep. Matt Shea
State Rep. Matt Shea
State Rep. Matt Shea

Taking a page from pre-Civil War politics, some Washington state lawmakers have introduced a slew of new libertarian bills attempting to block federal policies and peel back government regulation on everything from health care to firearms to hemp.

State Rep. Matt Shea, R-Spokane Valley, calls the effort the “Freedom Agenda.” Alongside a handful of other House members, Shea has introduced several bills aimed at preempting federal laws or limiting business regulation, in some cases making it a felony for a federal official to enforce an outlawed federal policy.

“The Freedom Agenda that I am proposing … is a means to protect our God-given freedoms that are guaranteed by the United States Constitution,” Shea says in a Jan. 22 video to constituents. “To preserve liberty and keep government limited, I will be fighting on your behalf in Olympia.”

Shea’s Health Care Freedom Act bill would allow the state to opt out of “Obamacare.” The Firearms Freedom Act, also a Freedom Agenda bill, would block any national assault-weapons ban. Another bill prohibits “cap and trade” limitations on greenhouse gases. Other proposed bills take on hemp regulations or international law.

But while the Freedom Agenda may reflect some popular conservative positions, any effort to block federal law will likely be symbolic at best.

The issue, ironically, rests with the division of power outlined in the U.S. Constitution. Since the Civil War, states have occasionally tried and failed to nullify federal policies they considered unreasonable by passing laws canceling them out. Southern states made similar attempts to block federal anti-segregation mandates during the Civil Rights era.

Brooks Holland, a constitutional law professor at Gonzaga University, says the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly struck down state-level attempts to undermine federal law. The Constitution and case law clearly establish the federal government’s supremacy on national regulations.

“The states cannot block or nullify national legislation [just] because they believe it’s bad policy,” Holland says.

So why pursue bills that may go nowhere? Shea declined to discuss the issue, keeping to a personal policy against speaking with The Inlander.

Also in News

Calling for Help

A frantic 911 call lands Christopher Parker in a jail cell instead of a hospital, and leads to his death

Jacob Jones |
Wednesday, May 22,2013

Let 'Em Vote

Spokane City Council won’t sue to keep initiatives off of the fall ballot; plus, a new UW-WSU rivalry

Heidi Groover, Deanna Pan, Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, May 22,2013

Reefer Rules

Washington state takes a first pass at marijuana market regulations

Heidi Groover, Lisa Waananen |
Wednesday, May 22,2013

Disorderly Conduct

Three Spokane law enforcement officers are placed on leave over misconduct investigations

Jacob Jones |
Wednesday, May 22,2013

Uneven Cuts

Most elements of health care were shielded from the sequester — but not the Indian Health Service

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, May 22,2013

Also By Jacob Jones

Who Ya Gonna Call?

The county’s 911 system crashes; plus, Olympia gets more male-dominated

Jacob Jones, Daniel Walters, Joe O'Sullivan |
Tuesday, November 27,2012

SPD Under Fire

A new report criticizes the professionalism of Spokane police; plus, courts strike down another anti-tax law

Jacob Jones, Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, March 6,2013

Polishing the Badge

Spokane Police get PR help; plus, sizing up a casino proposal

Jacob Jones, Daniel Walters |
Tuesday, February 5,2013

Swinging for Glory

Boxing champion Mikaela Mayer to fight alongside hundreds in national tournament

Jacob Jones |
Tuesday, April 2,2013

Blockbusted

Internet killed the video star

Jacob Jones |
Tuesday, February 12,2013


Conservatives remind me of Yosemite Sam or Elmer Fudd. They bring the guns, the stupidity, and of course, the failure. Feb 23, 2013 | Reply to this comment

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close