Pin It

Book Review - Hope's Edge 

by Marty Demarest

When Frances Moore Lappe wrote Diet for a Small Planet 30 years ago, she was confronting both an entrenched view of world hunger (there isn't enough food for everyone) and what sounded to her like an ominous solution (mass-produce more). But with the publication of her plain-spoken, heartfelt assessment on the ways in which unchecked consumerism was damaging both the environment and our health, some small changes started taking place.

Now, joining with her daughter Anna, Lapp & eacute; has chosen to revisit the same issues with the goal of looking at how much things have changed -- for better or worse. Like the title suggests, Hope's Edge is neither another dark assessment of the environmental condition nor a self-congratulatory account of improvements.

But this evenhanded approach quickly becomes the book's downfall, as Lapp & eacute; swerves frantically between exasperation and elation. What Diet for a Small Planet had as its driving force was conviction, which made it compelling even for readers who disagreed. Here, while Lapp & eacute; seems as convinced as ever of the need to improve the global food situation, she seems distracted by the myriad ways those improvements are slowly coming about.

Gone are the simple, well-reasoned arguments presented in the first book. In their place we have ambiguous assertions that, while she admires ranchers who raise free-range cattle, she still "can't quite relate," and that despite Starbucks' efforts to incorporate fair-trade coffee, it amounts to no more than a "token." Given her argument that the smallest wrong committed by an enormous corporation can lead to significant problems, it's strange to notice the omission of any speculation about where small improvements might lead.

Hope's Edge also contains a significant number of vegetarian recipes from cooks like Mollie Katzen and Alice Waters. But where Diet for a Small Planet provided information that was hard to find anywhere else at the time, Hope's Edge covers culinary territory that's now available in even the most casual bookstore. Perhaps if the space had been used to present new information and sound new calls to action, Lapp & eacute; could have continued her pioneering work. Unfortunately, what emerges is a book burdened with old ideologies confronting a new world.

  • Pin It

Latest in News

  • Odds And Ends
  • Odds And Ends

    Idaho lawmakers are pulled in lots of directions; plus, SPD weighs a "culture audit"
    • Mar 25, 2015
  • Four Days A Week
  • Four Days A Week

    Idaho schools that dropped one day a week from their schedule are saving a little money — but at what cost?
    • Mar 25, 2015
  • A County Ombudsman?
  • A County Ombudsman?

    Weighing the costs and benefits of oversight at the Spokane County Sheriff's Office
    • Mar 25, 2015
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri
Opening Day for Trails

Opening Day for Trails @ Spokane

Sat., March 28

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Marty Demarest

  • The Cowboy's Cowboy
  • The Cowboy's Cowboy

    A Canadian sings about the life —  not just the lifestyle — of the new West
    • May 15, 2013
  • Completing the Trilogy
  • Completing the Trilogy

    Mass Effect has finally arrived
    • May 23, 2012
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft

    Adventure and survival too often give way to mindless crafts in this building-block simulator.
    • Feb 8, 2012
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • Why Idaho kids don't go to college

    And what that means for the Gem State
    • Mar 4, 2015
  • New Blood

    Candidates are launching bids for Spokane City Council and could bring big changes to city government
    • Mar 18, 2015
  • More »

Top Tags in
News & Comment




Publisher's Note

long reads

© 2015 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation