Pin It


No, Caprica is not Battlestar Galactica

click to enlarge art14747.jpg

It may be set in the same galaxy, it may have Cylons, a dude named Adama, and people who unironically use the word “frak,” but Caprica is not Battlestar Galactica.

It’s a prequel, yes, set 58 years before the Battlestar, but it seems more spinoff: The Frasier to Battlestar’s Cheers.

Battlestar had three moods: Bleak, bleaker, and bleak with a vengeance. Caprica, however, starts out positively sunny (the occasional teenage suicide bombing aside) and then slides toward darkness.

Where Battlestar’s characters were drunk on despair, Caprica’s are drunk on optimism. It’s the future, after all, where space travel is commonplace, where living out any fantasy is a “holoband” away.

Daniel Graystone (Eric Stoltz), genius creator of the holoband technology, also dabbles a bit in robotics. He’s even developed a big gun-shootin’ model he calls a “Cylon.”

After Graystone’s daughter dies in a terrorist attack, he finds she’s made a perfect virtual copy of her own personality. Hey, Graystone figures, what if he uploaded his dead daughter’s personality into the killer robot body? Wouldn’t that be a fascinating experiment with very little chance for galaxy-wide repercussions?

What follows is less Battlestar Galactica — where humanity weathers its near-extinction — as the second season of Dollhouse. We know the apocalypse is inevitable. We can only watch as the doomed obliviously march toward it.

Good sci-fi — like Caprica, like Dollhouse — takes its interesting characters and uses them to explore the ol’ metaphysical classics: What does it mean to be “alive”? Do clones/droids/sentient galaxies have souls? Should the virtual world carry the same moral standards? If you rewrite or Xerox a personality, do you still have the same person?

Fortunately, Caprica coats the philosophical in the dramatic. Politics, betrayal, religion, revenge and dumb teenage love all play a bigger part than robots and cyberspace. While producer Ron Moore sometimes overdoes his hyperactive cinematography, Caprica is never lifeless. The slow scenes are never slow.

Caprica’s more grounded — literally and metaphorically — than its space-faring predecessor. That makes it less ambitious. But for all that, it has a more clear direction. This time, we can tell, they actually do have a plan.


Millionaire Matchmaker
Though scientists are working on it, so far, money can’t buy you love. At least, not directly. What it can buy is a spot in the Millionaire’s Club, where certified matchmaker Patti Stranger will separate soul mate from gold digger. Hear the ring of wedding bells sounding; hear the scratch of pre-nups being signed. (Tuesdays, 10 pm, Bravo)

The 82nd Academy Awards
Really-too-old-to-be-believable-in-romantic-comedies hosts Steve Martin and Alec Baldwin head up this year’s Oscars ceremonies. Watch to see if the Academy still cares about things like acting, writing, originality, logic, plot, dialogue and plausibly named hard-to-obtain geological elements, or if Avatar wins Best Picture. (Sunday, March 7, 5 pm on ABC)

The Marriage Ref
America’s marriages are in trouble. The percentage of single parents hovers around 50 percent, and the unhappily married level surely is even higher. “We could solve our problems, we could save our marriages,” America cries, “if only comedians like Jerry Seinfeld and Kelly Ripa could enter our homes and tell us who’s right and who’s wrong.” Perhaps. The Marriage Ref hopes to heal our nation’s soul. (Thursdays, 10 pm, NBC)

Follow Daniel Walters’ TV commentary on Twitter at @danieltwalters.


  • Pin It

Latest in Film

  • Origin-al Sins
  • Origin-al Sins

    Whatever Pan is supposed to provide a backstory for, it's not Peter Pan.
    • Oct 8, 2015
  • Helping Hand
  • Helping Hand

    Rosenwald reintroduces us to a great American hero
    • Oct 8, 2015
  • Drug Warriors
  • Drug Warriors

    Sicario is a tough, brutal film — and one of the year's best
    • Oct 1, 2015
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Sat | Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu
Bartfest feat. Angel Olsen, Lionlimb, Loch Lomond, Perenne

Bartfest feat. Angel Olsen, Lionlimb, Loch Lomond, Perenne @ The Bartlett

Fri., Oct. 9, 6:30 p.m.

All of today's events | Staff Picks


Most Commented On

  • Matt Damon vs. Outer Space

    The Martian is the optimistic sci-fi movie that Christopher Nolan failed to deliver
    • Oct 1, 2015
  • Rocker Soccer '83

    A busload of baby-faced rockers and a mysterious soccer match — trying to piece together an epic August day from long, long ago
    • Sep 24, 2015
  • More »

© 2015 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation