Pin It

Going Private? 

Initiative 1082 would allow private workers’ compensation insurance.

click to enlarge art15338.jpg

When a girder falls on a steel worker, the mill’s often legally responsible to compensate that worker for injuries and lost work time. To prepare for such a possibility, the mill is required, by law, to carry workers’ compensation insurance.

While the largest employers, like Boeing and Walmart, have enough cash to insure themselves, smaller businesses have only one option for workers’ compensation insurance: The state of Washington.

Since 10 years ago, when court decisions revamped the way workers’ compensation worked, business coalitions like the Building Industry Association of Washington have been urging the state Legislature to reform the workers’ compensation insurance rules. But each and every time, their proposals went nowhere.

The BIAW blames pressure from union; the Washington State Labor Council union blames “pretty bad ideas.”

But now the BIAW is taking the idea directly to the people with Initiative 1082. It would open the floodgates for private insurance companies — like AIG and Liberty Mutual Group — to compete with the state, ostensibly driving down prices. That’s good for private insurance companies. At least, Liberty Mutual, which donated $300,000 to support the initiative, evidently thinks so.

“The entire business community has signed on and endorsed this initiative,” says BIAW PR director Erin Shannon. “The business community believes that competition will provide a service and a product that’s the best quality for the best price, allowing competition will do what competition does in any market.”

But unions like the Washington State Labor Council strongly disagree with that assessment. For one, not all businesses support the initiative, and some like Revival Lighting in Spokane have publicly opposed it, saying it would drive up their costs.

Indeed, opponents of 1082 predict a dire scenario: Insurance companies would cherry-pick safer companies, offering them low premiums to woo them away from the public state insurance system. With the state left providing policies for only higher-risk businesses, those premiums would skyrocket, the WSLC worries. Think of it like a health insurance provider left providing only for smokers.

“That’s what’s happened in other states,” No on 1082 spokesman Alex Fryer says, citing West Virginia as an example.

“This is getting rid of the public nonprofit option,” says David Groves, a WSLC spokesman. He worries that for-profit insurance companies — with their desire for profits — will charge higher premiums for smaller benefits than the state would.

Currently, 46 other states allow the private sector to issue workers’ comp insurance. But Fryer says 1082 would actually allow private insurance companies to set their own rates without pre-approval from a regulatory agency — something no other state does.

Moreover, a study by the Oregon Department of Consumer and Business Services suggests that Washington state already has one of the best premium-to-benefit ratios in the country.

Under the surface, 1082’s rules are complicated.

Where employees currently pay a portion of their medical-coverage premiums, the initiative would remove that, requiring employers to pay the full sum.

“I’m going to have to eat the 25 percent that the employee pays,” Revival Lighting owner Janine Vaughn says. “And as a small business, that’s a lot of money for me.”

Meanwhile, businessmen like Ron Caferro, who owns Ecolite Manufacturing in Spokane, say passing the initiative is a necessity.

“The rates are out of control,” Caffero says. “I pay about a quarter of a million dollars of [Labors and Industries] premiums.”

The initiative would also allow groups like the BIAW, which pool their insurance funds, to collect portions of refunds from unabsorbed premiums. The state already has a similar program, but recent reforms have reduced the amount BIAW receives annually, Fryer says.

With 1082, those refunds could come from a private insurer. “This kickback is illegal for any other line of insurance and is intended to replenish the BIAW’s coffers,” writes Groves of the WSLC.

Shannon denies that’s a motive for BIAW’s support of 1082.

  • Pin It

Speaking of Politics, election 2010

  • Ugly Breakup
  • Ugly Breakup

    The long-running rift between the mayor and the city council president just got worse
    • Jun 9, 2016
  • Beggs for a Solution
  • Beggs for a Solution

    In the three months Breean Beggs has been on the council, he's pitched out-of-the-box ideas for some of the city's stickiest problems
    • Jun 2, 2016
  • Rush To Judgment
  • Rush To Judgment

    A complaint against council assistant Richard Rush tests the council's ability to handle HR concerns — but was Rush's firing fair?
    • May 12, 2016
  • More »

Latest in News

  • Crash > Click > Cash
  • Crash > Click > Cash

    Lawyers and chiropractors already have your name, your address and the police report from your car accident — and they want you to hire them
    • Jul 21, 2016
  • Starting Small
  • Starting Small

    A village of tiny houses in Spokane Valley could serve as a model for fighting homelessness in the region
    • Jul 21, 2016
  • Drastic Action
  • Drastic Action

    Spokane among seven school districts sued by State Superintendent of Public Instruction; plus, trio of police-chief finalists are in town
    • Jul 21, 2016
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun | Mon | Tue
The Golden Spike

The Golden Spike @ Spark Center

Fri., July 29, 10 a.m.-6 p.m.

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Daniel Walters

Most Commented On

  • Lane Ends Ahead

    Spokane wants to improve a mile-long section of Monroe — but that means taking away two lanes
    • Jul 7, 2016
  • Too Smart for School

    What happens when a 12-year-old prodigy tries to go to college in Spokane?
    • Jun 30, 2016
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Hopeless for Heroin
  • Hopeless for Heroin

    As heroin deaths continue to rise in Washington state, what can a parent do to save a child from the depths of addiction?
    • Jul 29, 2015
  • Cease-Fire
  • Cease-Fire

    What will Congress' new tolerance for medical marijuana mean for people facing federal drug charges?
    • Dec 23, 2014

© 2016 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation