Pin It
Favorite

Idaho to D.C.: No, Thanks 

Gem State lawmakers aren't interested in reform and send the Health Freedom Act to the governor

click to enlarge art14806.jpg

Congress is still wrestling over how to reform health care, but this much seems clear: Idaho isn’t interested.

The Idaho Senate recently passed the Health Freedom Act, which would essentially exclude Idaho from federal health care legislation, requiring it to sue if Congress requires people to purchase health insurance.

The bill is now on Gov. Butch Otter’s desk and, according to news reports, he is almost guaranteed to sign it.

Senate sponsor Sen. Monty Pearce (R-New Plymouth) says Idaho joins about 30 states across the country that are pushing legislation that sends a clear message to the feds that it is overstepping its boundaries.

“I can’t believe the federal government would be making us all do something,” he says. “It’s never happened before in history. To force us to purchase something against our will is wrong.”

Pearce says health care belongs in the hands of individuals and that a federal health care plan would be neither cheap nor efficient. He believes Idaho stands to succeed if it ultimately goes to court to fight for health care freedom.

“I’m against government being where it doesn’t belong…” he says. “I think there’s room for states to push back.”

Rep. George Sayler (D-Coeur d’Alene) says Idaho can push back all it wants, but odds are the federal government won’t budge.

“Historically when states challenge federal law, they don’t do very well in court,” he says.

Sayler, who voted against the bill, says it doesn’t make sense to challenge a federal health law before they know exactly what it’s going to include.

“It’s part of the general anti-federal government movement that’s going around,” he says. “I don’t support that.”

David Irwin of AARP Idaho says the bill doesn’t tackle any of the issues that Idaho needs to address, including high prescription drug and insurance prices and rising levels of uninsured residents, and would instead act as a roadblock to progress.

In addition, Irwin says the legislation could cost Idaho $1.6 billion in federal health care funds and thousands of state health care jobs. The AARP Idaho has publicly opposed the bill.

“What it will do to Idaho’s health care system is not a pretty picture,” he says.

The Health Freedom Act sets aside $100,000 for Idaho to take the issue to court, but Sayler says it would likely cost the state even more from the constitutional defense fund — money that could be spent more wisely in tough economic times.

Pearce says the Goldwater Institute, an independent government watchdog group, is prepared to defend Idaho in court. “The Goldwater Institute would fight the battle for us,” he says. “It wouldn’t cost the state anything.”

Irwin points out that the institute isn’t mentioned in the bill and says there’s no guarantee it would defend Idaho. “Legislation specifies it’s the attorney general’s job to do so,” he says.

Sayler says the bill is a product of partisanship, demonstrated by the fact that House and Senate votes were almost completely divided down party lines. While Republicans are sending their message loud and clear, he says the alternative to health care reform, the status quo, is unacceptable for Idaho.

“We all agree that there needs to be health care reform,” he says. “It may not be perfect… but this isn’t contributing in a positive way.”

Tags:

  • Pin It

Latest in News

  • Barred from Help
  • Barred from Help

    Why mentally ill inmates continue to languish in the Spokane County Jail
    • Jul 22, 2015
  • Envision This!
  • Envision This!

    DSP is fighting the proposed Worker Bill of Rights; plus, finalists for Spokane's police ombudsman
    • Jul 22, 2015
  • Shake Down
  • Shake Down

    When a 9.0 magnitude earthquake rocks Western Washington, what will happen in the Inland Northwest?
    • Jul 22, 2015
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun | Mon
Moscow ArtWalk 2015

Moscow ArtWalk 2015 @ Downtown Moscow

Tuesdays, Thursdays, Sundays. Continues through Aug. 31

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Natalie Johnson

  • Last Call
  • Last Call

    Caught between politics and law, Parkside Bistro and Pub will soon be bulldozed.
    • May 12, 2010
  • Getting Gassed
  • Getting Gassed

    In the struggle of squirrels versus humanity, who takes precedence?
    • Apr 28, 2010
  • Brian, Meet Sediba
  • Brian, Meet Sediba

    In South Africa, a mother and her child fell into a sinkhole and died. Two million years later, a WSU grad found their bones
    • Apr 21, 2010
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • Patrolling While Black

    Gordon Grant's nearly 30 years as a Spokane cop have been affected by race, but that's not the whole story
    • Jul 8, 2015
  • Rushing's Rant

    The Airway Heights City Council has asked the mayor to resign after posting a racist Facebook message
    • Jul 15, 2015
  • More »

© 2015 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation