Pin It
Favorite

Prints Raise Brows 

A proposal to scan elementary students' fingerprints draws fire from parents before being put on hold.

click to enlarge art16932.jpg

Spokane Public Schools last week put on hold a plan to fingerprint students, which had been criticized by parents and civil liberties groups as an unnecessary invasion of privacy.

Doug Wordell, nutrition services director for Spokane Public Schools, says the proposal was intended to move breakfast and lunch lines faster by having students scan their fingers in order to receive their food, rather than using a simple checklist.

“The intent was that we move lines well and feed kids,” says Wordell, who oversees the 17,000 lunches and 5,500 breakfasts served by the system daily. He added that the program was meant to double the number of free or low-cost breakfasts and lunches the school district serves. “With this particular piece, the key that I felt good about is that it’s a finger scan, it’s not duplicable, it’s encrypted so it wouldn’t be available.”

The worry is that the information gathered could be misused by the school district, says Kiondra Bullock, who has a daughter at Linwood Elementary School.

“I think that the school district should abandon this idea all together,” says Bullock, the executive director of VOICES, a Spokane nonprofit that advocates for low-income people. She says the schools should focus instead on making their breakfasts more nutritious.

Rebecca Jeschke, spokeswoman for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a national civil liberties group, says fingerprints could be mined for a variety of data. They could be used in court proceedings to determine a child’s location at a given time, Jeschke say. Or if they fell into the wrong hands, they could be misused for other purposes, too — even after the students were out of school.

“This is sensitive information,” Jeschke says.

“Someone could conceivably get a new Social Security number. They can’t get new fingerprints.”

Wordell says the fingerprints that have been collected are stored on secure school district computers as alphanumeric figures. He says the district abandoned the program this summer and any prints collected so far will be deleted sometime this week.

Currently, cafeteria workers use classroom lists to determine if a student has signed up for a meal. Most students are familiar to employees, Wordell says, and lines are typically manageable.

But the lines can grow, he adds, on days when there are substitute workers who are unfamiliar with the students, or when there are unforeseen circumstances, like a late school bus arrival. So, he says, he started looking for a faster way to verify if students had paid for a meal.

“I used to use [swipe] cards as an example. Kids stand in line, and we’re specifically talking about elementary level, and kids start bending them,” or trading them among their friends, Wordell says. Hence the use of fingerprints.

Pilot programs began last spring at Holmes and Stevens elementary schools, where the fingerprints of about 100 students per school were collected using the school cafeteria’s computer system, Wordell says. Parents initially had to opt their children out of the fingerprinting, but if the program is revived in the future, Wordell says parents will instead have to opt in.

After looking at his schedule for the recently commenced school year, as well as hearing concerns from parents about the fingerprints being subpoenaed, Wordell decided to put the pilot project on hold.

“There was certainly some feedback. As a result, we want to make sure we ask the right questions,” Wordell says. “We certainly want it to be positive if we do it at all.”

Parents weren’t the only group to take notice.

A letter dated Aug. 9 from Doug Klunder, privacy counsel for the American Civil Liberties Union of Washington, encouraged Spokane Public Schools Superintendent Nancy Stowell to abandon the program.

However, Doug Honig, spokesman for the ACLU of Washington, says the practice does not violate any state laws.

The technology has received a cool reception elsewhere. School districts in Colorado, California, Massachusetts and Arizona have abandoned plans to incorporate fingerprinting into meal plans, the ACLU letter reads.

In 2007, Illinois enacted a law that says biometric information, like fingerprints, may only be collected with parental consent. Arizona enacted a similar measure in 2008.

If the circumstances are right, Wordell says, he would consider reattempting a biometric system for lunches.

“We want to make sure we do some good research on it, [and] make sure we communicate with schools, communicate with parents,” he says. “It might be something [that would] become an effective way to move our lines.”

  • Pin It

Speaking of Privacy, education

  • 'Cautiously Optimistic'
  • 'Cautiously Optimistic'

    Spokane Public Schools has seen improvement since committing to reducing suspensions, but the hardest part is yet to come
    • Feb 16, 2017
  • Global Outreach
  • Global Outreach

    Washington State University plans to admit more international students to compete with top schools. But will that hurt in-state students?
    • Jan 26, 2017
  • 'It Shouldn't of Happened'
  • 'It Shouldn't of Happened'

    North Idaho College never questioned the men implicated in an alleged gang rape; instead, school officials scrutinized their accuser
    • Jan 5, 2017
  • More »

Latest in News

  • In Their Best Interest
  • In Their Best Interest

    Why many neglected kids don't have legal representation for critical decisions that could dictate their future
    • Feb 23, 2017
  • 'Right Side of History'
  • 'Right Side of History'

    The Washington Supreme Court rules against Arlene's Flowers; plus, two dogs call it a day
    • Feb 23, 2017
  • Frozen Out
  • Frozen Out

    In the middle of a chaotic winter, the city of Spokane ousted its veteran street director, but won't give an explanation to the city council
    • Feb 23, 2017
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Patrolling While Black
  • Patrolling While Black

    Gordon Grant's nearly 30 years as a Spokane cop have been affected by race, but that's not the whole story
    • Jul 8, 2015
  • Manufacturing Fear
  • Manufacturing Fear

    Spokane's Republican sheriff says members of his own party are dangerously dividing people
    • Aug 12, 2015
  • Dinner, Drinks and Doobies?
  • Dinner, Drinks and Doobies?

    A new initiative would allow weed in Denver bars and restaurants; any chance Washington would follow suit?
    • Oct 15, 2015

Comments

Showing 1-1 of 1

 

Comments are closed.

Today | Fri | Sat | Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed
A Little Night Music

A Little Night Music @ Spokane Civic Theatre

Thursdays-Saturdays, 7:30 p.m. and Sundays, 2 p.m. Continues through March 5

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Chris Stein

  • Ready for Anything
  • Ready for Anything

    Developing agility may help prevent injury
    • Sep 1, 2012
  • PAML's Next Step
  • PAML's Next Step

    Francisco Velazquez insists on symmetry. Even sitting at a huge table flanked by leather-backed chairs and a jumble of expensive video equipment, he makes sure his Blackberry and iPhone (the former for business, the latter for pleasure) are situated in neat symmetry with each other.
    • Sep 1, 2012
  • Burns Out
  • Burns Out

    As the city scrambles to keep Tim Burns around for a while longer, the police ombudsman says he may leave his post anyway
    • Aug 22, 2012
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • We Have Not Yet Begun to Fight

    Why we're filling the streets to protest Trump's inhumane, dangerous policies
    • Feb 2, 2017
  • Obscene Gestures

    Spokane political party leaders hope to harness post-election passion into civil discourse. But so far, there's only been more strife
    • Feb 9, 2017
  • More »

Top Tags in
News & Comment

Briefs


green zone


marijuana


Comment


do something


Readers also liked…

  • Shake Down
  • Shake Down

    When an earthquake rocks Western WA, what will happen in the Inland Northwest?
    • Jul 22, 2015
  • Hopeless for Heroin
  • Hopeless for Heroin

    As heroin deaths continue to rise in Washington state, what can a parent do to save a child from the depths of addiction?
    • Jul 29, 2015
  • Manufacturing Fear
  • Manufacturing Fear

    Spokane's Republican sheriff says members of his own party are dangerously dividing people
    • Aug 12, 2015

© 2017 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation