Pin It

Scratch Sweets 

Homemade gelato at a Spirit Lake pizzeria. Plus, lasagna - it's on ya.

click to enlarge Homemade gelato at Fourth - CARRIE SCOZZARO
  • Carrie Scozzaro
  • Homemade gelato at Fourth

The number of North Idaho places selling gelato tripled recently, thanks to an unlikely source in Spirit Lake, a rustic town of around 2,000 people along the northwestern rim of Kootenai County. That’s where Randi and Jeff Malloy have operated Fourth and Main Pizza since 2003, making most everything from scratch: pizza dough, sauce, sausage, even the bread for their sandwiches.

“Better quality and better taste,” says Randi, who handles pizza and sandwiches, assisted by her father, Bob Billings, during lunch. And now Jeff devotes mornings and late nights — when he’s not working with his brother in their computer business — to making gelato.

Food and family are important to the Malloys, whose five children have worked in the restaurant. Their youngest son, Adam, took credit for encouraging dad to make unusual flavors like smoked bacon. But it was their daughter, Nicole, who indirectly introduced the Malloys to gelato. While traveling Europe with Nicole (a budding pastry chef), Randi and Jeff visited Rome’s Gelateria del Teatro, a highly regarded artisan gelateria. They were hooked.

Countless hours spent training and experimenting have yielded around 75 gelato flavors and 20 sorbets, all made from scratch with their own caramels, roasted nuts, fruit purees and flavorings. You won’t find any powderbased gelato here. A case of egg yolks every other week equals 30 batches of gelato — six quarts per batch. Try chocolatey tartufo, coconut or espresso, or opt for the light pineapple sorbet ($2.50- $3.50).

You can also find the Malloys’ gelato at Rathdrum’s San Francisco Sourdough Eatery and Coeur d’Alene’s Frosted Cupcakes. Jeff currently has his hands full preparing gelato for Coeur d’Alene’s Art on the Green (Aug. 5-7) and the Spirit Lake Red Wine and Bluz Fest (Aug. 19-20).

Winter might bring some relief for the Malloys, adds Randi. But that’s when they’re going to start making their own pasta. Just another reason to take a little drive out to Spirit Lake. (Carrie Scozzaro)

Fourth & Main Pizza • 6185 W. Maine St., Spirit Lake, Idaho • Open Mon-Thu 11 am–8 pm, Fri-Sat 11 am-9 pm • (208) 623-6246.

Take and Bake

If you don’t live on the north side, here’s a reason to brave the construction on North Division to get there: drive-thru lasagna. At Lasagna's-On-Ya, you can pick up a wholesome, scratch-made meal for just a little more than the cost of those “other” drive-thrus. Of course, you can always walk inside and pick up your order, but that’s not nearly as much fun.

“I have six daughters and we were always thinking of different lasagna ideas,” says Jennifer Shorts, who opened the business with her husband, Dan, last October. “It’s just what we do.”

Today, the Shorts family is serving up five different kinds of lasagna — recipes they’ve perfected over years of feeding hungry teenagers.

The classic meat lasagna is the most popular. A close second is the Tuscan chicken, a creamy, cheesy concoction with bacon, chicken, artichoke hearts and pesto. I tried not to think of the calorie content — it was definitely rich. The smallest size is meant to serve one to two ($12) but would easily satisfy three medium appetites, with a large salad and bread.

Vegetarian, mushroom and meat, and chicken Alfredo lasagnas are also available. Any of the lasagnas can be made gluten-free and can be ordered with salad and rustic baguettes to make a complete meal. Lean lasagna is available by special order, made with chicken, fresh vegetables and a hearty red sauce. Maybe next time I’ll order that one, so I can save room for some locally made cheesecake with huckleberry sauce or a slice of tiramisu.

Just pop the lasagna in the oven and dinner’s ready in 15 to 30 minutes, depending on the size. Lasagna’s-On-Ya offers four sizes, from single-serve to a “grande” lasagna that serves up to 12. Prices range from $10 to $49.

If you’re still not willing to brave the construction, the lasagnas are also available at the South Perry Farmers Market on Thursdays and the Liberty Lake Farmers Market on Saturdays. (Kirsten Harrington)

Lasagna’s-On-Ya • 521 E. Holland Ave. • Open Mon-Sat 11 am-8 pm, Sun noon-5 pm • 467-9100


  • Pin It

Latest in Food & Drink

  • A Good Foundation
  • A Good Foundation

    An exploration of the very different kinds of pizza crust found in Spokane
    • Dec 1, 2016
  • Hops 
and Hogs
  • Hops and Hogs

    How a gearhead's love of beer resulted in V Twin Brewing Company
    • Nov 23, 2016
  • Teamwork
  • Teamwork

    Artisan cider and mead come together at Solace in Kendall Yards
    • Nov 23, 2016
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat
Chris Bovey: My Spokane

Chris Bovey: My Spokane @ Northwest Museum of Arts & Culture

Tuesdays-Sundays. Continues through Jan. 8

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Carrie Scozzaro

  • Grains of Truth
  • Grains of Truth

    Shaun Thompson Duffy goes from mill to oven
    • Nov 29, 2016
  • Taking Care of Business
  • Taking Care of Business

    Locally owned 777 offers a different approach to the cook-it-yourself pizza
    • Nov 23, 2016
  • Native Passion
  • Native Passion

    Jacob Johns is an artist and activist who does a little of everything
    • Nov 3, 2016
  • More »

More by Kirsten Harrington

  • Coupon Culture
  • Coupon Culture

    How local shoppers save big and help others
    • Jun 19, 2012
  • Fulfilling the Hype
  • Fulfilling the Hype

    The long-awaited Casper Fry opens in the Perry District.
    • Jun 6, 2012
  • Sushi Reimagined
  • Sushi Reimagined

    Roll Story puts a casual, quick spin on gourmet Japanese fare.
    • May 23, 2012
  • More »

Most Commented On

Readers also liked…

  • Perfect Pairing
  • Perfect Pairing

    Slice and Grind is ready to introduce you to Amish food
    • Jun 23, 2016
  • A Missing Link
  • A Missing Link

    LINC Foods helps connect the region's biggest food buyers with the smallest producers
    • May 27, 2015

© 2016 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation