Pin It
Favorite

The Black Dahlia 

Los Angeles, 1947. The body of a beautiful, young aspiring actress is found cut in half at the waist, her cheeks slashed to give her a macabre, post-mortem smile. Chunks of her flesh have been neatly cut out. The body is clean. Her eyes are wide open.

Whodunnit? No one knows. The newspapers go crazy and dub her "the Black Dahlia," after The Blue Dahlia, a film from the year before. Her real name is Elizabeth Short. She's from small-town Massachusetts. The LAPD entertains hundreds of suspects, interviews thousands. Still, nothing but empty leads, even now, 60 years later.

Real sensational stuff. Of course, I learned all of that from Wikipedia and amateur sleuth Web pages. Brian De Palma's film didn't shed much light. With its stylized cover seeming to promise a dark, twisted journey deep into the bowels of the case, the movie instead uses Los Angeles' most notorious unsolved murder as the mere background for a confused, disjointed story about two detectives investigating the case and how it makes them feel.

Of course, that's not entirely De Palma's fault. The film is an adaptation of the novel by James Ellroy. But De Palma, for his part, is at least guilty of miscasting, flawed execution and a jumbled storyline. Black Dahlia's two protagonist cops (Aaron Eckhart and Josh Hartnett) are undeveloped. The normally scintillating Scarlett Johansson is laughable as a '40s seductress. And why does Hilary Swank -- as the spoiled daughter of a Hollywood magnate -- keep noting her uncanny resemblance to Mia Kirshner (as Short) when it couldn't be further from the truth?

The film intends to show how the Dahlia case unravels the lives of everyone it touches, but in the end it's only the film that unravels -- to the point that the "solving" of the unsolved case just seems like a footnote at the end.

The DVD's wealth of bonus features should have supplemented the film with a deeper look into the case itself. It doesn't. Although James Ellroy provides some background regarding the differences between the real case and the film, it does more to illustrate those between the book and the film, and reality's left behind again. There's a nice section on the De Palma touch -- his use of color and camera motion. But such back-patting for such a flawed film is, well, a mystery. (Rated R)

  • Pin It

Latest in Film

  • Swing and a Miss
  • Swing and a Miss

    Hands of Stone can't carve out a distinctive space among boxing biopics
    • Aug 25, 2016
  • Texas Heat
  • Texas Heat

    Hell or High Water is the crime drama you've been waiting all summer for
    • Aug 25, 2016
  • Master of Puppets
  • Master of Puppets

    Kubo and the Two Strings is a gorgeous, if conventional, epic journey
    • Aug 18, 2016
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun | Mon | Tue

All of today's events | Staff Picks

or

More by Joel Smith

Most Commented On

  • Still Celebrating

    Boy George and Culture Club paved the way for genre- and gender-bending rock stars
    • Aug 11, 2016
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Where Are the Women?
  • Where Are the Women?

    A critic's year-long deep dive into the way movies portray half of humanity
    • May 12, 2016
  • Behind the Music
  • Behind the Music

    The Grammy Awards are about much more than what you see on TV
    • Feb 11, 2015

© 2016 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation