Pin It
Favorite

The Zimmer Appraisal 

by Ted S. McGregor , Jr.


If every court case is a work in progress, questions posed in depositions can offer a glimpse at where an attorney is taking his or her case. In the deposition of Betsy Cowles taken last month, Gary Ceriani, the lead attorney for the plaintiffs in the federal case about the failing River Park Square parking garage, may have tipped his hand a bit. In earlier depositions, the document known as the Zimmer appraisal came up a couple times. But in Cowles' depo, Ceriani spent a lot of time on that document, suggesting he may rely on it to make his case.


In 1996, the River Park Square development team hired Derek Zimmer to do an appraisal of the garage to determine a potential price for the city to pay. Later, the city paid for two other appraisals. Ceriani, however, seems to be asking what good those two were -- the Barrett and Auble appraisals. After all, the price ultimately presented to the city ($29.79 million) came from Zimmer, not the others.


But the real trouble, Ceriani alleges, is that River Park Square never shared the details of the Zimmer appraisal with the city. And it wasn't included in the Official Statement, either. Cowles testified that she believed the city knew the contents of the report, although she said it might have been held back at first.


Ceriani: Now, there were some documents, however, that the developer did not share with the City, correct?


Cowles: Well, I'm sure there were -- yes, there were.


GC: In fact, one of those documents was the Zimmer appraisal, right?


BC: The Zimmer -- the City of Spokane knew about the Zimmer appraisal and knew the numbers in it. I don't have knowledge whether in fact whether or not someone with the City had a, had or saw a copy of the document.


GC: Did you have any reservation about providing a copy of the Zimmer appraisal to representatives of the City -- you personally?


BC: I recall believing that it was a work product, a proprietary work product of ours. And at that point in time in the project, I still believed that there was a private side of the project.


City officials have testified that they never were provided with a copy of that report. Les Weatherhead, attorney for River Park Square, says the city had a summary of it, knew its conclusion and the fact that Zimmer didn't rely on Walker. And Weatherhead points out that the ultimate price paid was negotiated down from the figure calculated by Zimmer.


Cowles agrees: "[Zimmer] was looking at a different number of seats [in the theaters], and he was not a parking expert. We shared all the relevant information with the city. If the city had asked for the document, I don't see why I wouldn't have given it to them."


The significance of the Zimmer appraisal to the plaintiffs is that it contradicted Walker. Zimmer didn't use Walker's projections, as the other appraisers did. Instead, he made a few calls on his own and put together a parking demand analysis all his own. Zimmer predicted significantly lower revenues than Walker, but he still arrived at the $29 million price using the investment value method.


Weatherhead says calling Zimmer a criticism of Walker is a stretch; they were just two different documents used to understand the project. "The sales price was negotiated; when you're bargaining, all kinds of information is used."


Still, in the effort to prove that there was information available to some or all of the development team that contradicted the Walker Report, it looks as if the Zimmer appraisal may be the plaintiffs' Exhibit A.





Publication date: 05/22/03
  • Pin It

Latest in Comment

  • Clinton In Command
  • Clinton In Command

    While Obama and Trump may believe that American global leadership is over, Hillary Clinton sees things differently
    • Sep 29, 2016
  • Debate Decorum
  • Debate Decorum

    Trail Mix: Trump's weighty attacks and Inslee/Bryant showdown
    • Sep 29, 2016
  • Building on the Past
  • Building on the Past

    With dynamic new leadership, Coeur d'Alene is starting to make the dream of a high-tech economy come to life
    • Sep 29, 2016
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri
Spokane-Cagli Sister City Ceremony

Spokane-Cagli Sister City Ceremony @ Doubletree Hotel

Sat., Oct. 1

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Ted S. McGregor Jr.

  • <b>From Crimson &#10;to Purple</b>
  • From Crimson to Purple

    Bob Gregory was a Spokane-bred Cougar through and through; now he's prowling the sidelines for the Huskies
    • Sep 1, 2016
  • After the Deluge
  • After the Deluge

    Cleaning up Trump's hot mess is going to take some heroic leadership
    • Sep 1, 2016
  • Staying Engaged
  • Staying Engaged

    From the Mayfair Cafe to Central Park
    • Aug 4, 2016
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • To Kill the Black Snake

    Historic all-tribes protest at Standing Rock is meant to stop the destruction of the earth for all
    • Sep 8, 2016
  • Murrow's Nightmare

    Debate moderators need to be much more than an onstage prop to make our democracy work
    • Sep 15, 2016
  • More »

Top Tags in
News & Comment

election 2016


trail mix


BRIEFS


green zone


marijuana


Readers also liked…

  • To Kill the Black Snake
  • To Kill the Black Snake

    Historic all-tribes protest at Standing Rock is meant to stop the destruction of the earth for all
    • Sep 8, 2016
  • A Persistent Life
  • A Persistent Life

    Scott Reed won more cases than he lost in life, and the beauty of the Coeur d'Alene area has been the beneficiary
    • May 27, 2015

© 2016 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation