Pin It
Favorite

Until proven guilty 

& & by Sara Edlin-Marlowe & & & &





Saturday night, I journeyed out to the Lake City Playhouse in Coeur d'Alene to see 12 Angry Men. I must applaud Lake City Playhouse for finding 12 competent men to fill the bill. It's obvious that the Lake City has a community that supports its little theater.


This is not a long play, but it tells an intriguing story. My expectations of a dry courtroom drama were overcome, and I was quickly drawn into the conflict. The play immediately reminds us just how easily human beings judge one another -- we are so eager to label a person by ethnicity, religion, neighborhood or just by the company one keeps. The script frequently mentions that we live in a democracy where a person is innocent until proven guilty. But sometimes a case looks like a no-brainer, as does the case before our onstage jury, in which a 19-year-old boy is on trial for stabbing his father.


At the beginning, the judge tells the jurors through a voice-over that their decision must be unanimous. And it looks close to being so when 11 members of the jury find him guilty. But the twelfth juror, an architect, disagrees, throwing the jury room into uproar as the jury foreman and the rest of his peers try to convince him otherwise. The play asks us to examine the evidence for ourselves, just as it asks us to look at our ability to think with both logic and emotion.


This play began its life as a television drama written by Reginald Rose; adapted by Sherman Sergel, it has become a classic portrayal of a jury and the American justice system. Most of you know the movie by the same name, but this reviewer must admit, it was my first voyage into this material.


The Lake City production is directed by Charles I. Gift, the theater's technical director. I believe it's one of his first ventures into directing since his college days at Gonzaga. Directing is a craft that takes a long time to master, much like acting, and I'm sure we'll see more of Gift's work as he grows and takes on more projects. He is fortunate to have a very fine piece of literature and 12 able actors. The play flowed fairly well, although there were some moments when the hand of the director was very obvious. One hopes that there is a blending of the actor and director into a seamless tapestry.


You could describe the set as minimalist: a table, 12 chairs, a fan, an easel (which should have been brought in later in the action), a water cooler and one window. It's all you need, but you do need the actors to engage in activities that make their confinement believable, and each has the responsibility to create a character literally in a vacuum. We know nothing about these men -- like what they do outside of this small space -- but we begin to make judgments based on their behavior. And, indeed, they are making an important judgment: whether this young man on trial is guilty or innocent.


The drama held my interest. And I honestly had no idea how it would turn out. There were some powerful moments when the men were able to inhabit the space with actions and movements that communicated to us the urgency of the situation -- like when the ad man drew on a yellow pad, or when the immigrant gentleman (with all the humorous lines) reminded us of our democratic system or the outburst of the bigot. Since they didn't give names, I had code names for them all: the Foreman, Macho Man, the Button Down guy, the Suit, the Dignified Old Man, the Outsider and the Dissenter.


Mention must go to several of the men for very convincing performances: Al Potts, Russ Haleen, Daniel Cottrell, Vince Aurora and Darrell Louks were particularly effective. Don Lynn, Ed Muehlbach and Jeff Knapp offered solid support work, and Mark Hartley, Marvin Tyack and Gerald Cantrall completed the puzzle. There were only a few moments at the top of Act One and during Act Two when energy lagged, but most of the time the men kept the tension and brought the drama to the climax and resolution -- in this case, the final verdict.


Aristotle says in his Poetics that one of drama's goals is to teach us, along with entertaining us. This is one play that points out that we all need to suspend our judgments and be open to all possibilities.

  • Pin It

Latest in News

  • Cherry Pitfalls
  • Cherry Pitfalls

    Why fruit is rotting on trees while workers wait at the border
    • Jul 1, 2015
  • The Real Threats
  • The Real Threats

    What worries Spokane's sheriff; plus, Washington's lawmakers finally hash out a budget
    • Jul 1, 2015
  • Party of Five?
  • Party of Five?

    Why Spokane County's newest commissioner is leading the fight to add two more
    • Jul 1, 2015
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Today | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun | Mon
Moscow ArtWalk 2015

Moscow ArtWalk 2015 @ Downtown Moscow

Tuesdays, Thursdays, Sundays. Continues through Aug. 31

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Sara Edlin-Marlowe

  • Happy humbugs

    You've gotta love the fact that one of the most beloved Christmas stories of all time deals with misanthropy, hauntings, death, cynicism and poverty. And yet that's no doubt part of A Christmas Carol's charm. You wouldn't think the s
    • Nov 21, 2001
  • Tooling around O'Toole

    Spokane Civic Theatre opened its 55th season with a musical that drew me back into a world that I vividly recall: the l950s. It was a time when we huddled around television, mesmerized by the ability to have entertainment in our own
    • Oct 4, 2001
  • Dazzling and dark

    Cabaret came to life first in a collection of short stories by Christopher Isherwood entitled Berlin Stories; it then evolved into John Van Druten's play, I Am a Camera. Through the years, I was fortunate to see the original play (ba
    • Jul 2, 2001
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • The Rachel We Knew

    EDITOR'S NOTE: How Rachel Dolezal came to write for the Inlander
    • Jun 18, 2015
  • The Real Rachel Dolezal

    The story goes far beyond just a white woman portraying herself as black
    • Jun 17, 2015
  • More »

© 2015 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation