Tipping Point

The Spokane City Council tips a little to the left, Washington state shoots down GMO labeling and, as of press time, the levy to buy land around Fairchild was failing

Candance Mumm, backed by Council President Ben Stuckart, celebrates Tuesday night. - SARAH WURTZ
Sarah Wurtz
Candance Mumm, backed by Council President Ben Stuckart, celebrates Tuesday night.


Even in a non-presidential year and in a technically nonpartisan race, Tuesday's election sent a clear message about the city's current political leanings. With wins for Candace Mumm and Jon Snyder, the Spokane City Council will shift from a 4-3 conservative majority to a union-backed liberal one.

In the contentious bid to fill conservative Nancy McLaughlin's seat representing northwest Spokane, Mumm led conservative Michael Cannon 54-45 percent as of press time. The race drew more than $150,000 in campaign contributions and PAC-funded attack ads on TV and in the mail. In the end, money won the day for Mumm who out-fundraised Cannon by $25,000.

"The voters I talked to knew I'm a get-'er-done girl, and that's what they wanted," Mumm said among a group of supporters sipping red wine at the Kendall Yards neighborhood clubhouse Tuesday night. "They didn't like all the politics."

Michael Cannon and fiancée Jodey Miller check early results Tuesday night at their home. - YOUNG KWAK
Young Kwak
Michael Cannon and fiancée Jodey Miller check early results Tuesday night at their home.

The ideological divide was clear as Cannon — who sat on Mayor David Condon's transition team and chairs the city's Housing and Human Services Board — aligned almost entirely with Condon. Meanwhile, Mumm stood behind liberal Council President Ben Stuckart. The candidates clashed on whether the city should implement a 1 percent property tax increase in the 2014 budget, whether the council should strengthen the city's sit-lie law and whether the mayor's recent moves to increase the number of exempt city positions (in which employees are appointed rather than hired through civil service) were beneficial or dangerous.

Cannon saw support from Condon, conservative councilmen Steve Salvatori and Mike Allen and a PAC funded primarily by local construction firms, homebuilder groups and City Administrator Theresa Sanders. Prominent local liberals like Rich Cowan, state Sen. Andy Billig and Stuckart lined up behind Mumm, a former TV news reporter and Plan Commission member who worked on Mary Verner's re-election campaign against Condon. Drawing conservative ire, most of her big contributions came from local and state unions, including firefighters, health care workers and county and city employees.

Incumbent Councilman Jon Snyder, a transportation-focused member of the council's current liberal minority, held his seat representing the South Hill, Peaceful Valley and Browne's Addition against a challenge from Republican and former state Rep. John Ahern. While their race never got as testy as the other, Snyder criticized Ahern for being short on specifics and energy. Ahern challenged Snyder on whether he'd done enough to make the city business-friendly, promising he'd look to loosen regulations. Snyder says he was confident he'd hold onto his seat Tuesday, but was "thrilled" with the nearly 30 percent margin by which he won. Ahern, meanwhile, warned of the impact union-supported victories could have on the city.

"I don't want to see Spokane wind up like Detroit did," Ahern told the Inlander after results were announced. "The unions that ran Detroit pretty much over-demanded and got too much. That's why Detroit went bankrupt. Spokane could be on the same road. You get pretty much what you ask for." — HEIDI GROOVER


After $27 million and seven months of campaigning, it appears Washington won't become the first state in the country to mandate labeling of genetically engineered foods after all. Early returns on Tuesday night showed Initiative 522 was failing statewide 45 percent to 55 percent. Voters had rejected I-522 in all but three counties — Jefferson, King and Whatcom. In Spokane, 62 percent voted against the measure.

Labeling supporters, however, were cautiously optimistic about their initiative's chances.

"It is really too close to call. We have hundreds of thousands of votes left to be counted in King County alone," says Elizabeth Larter, a spokeswoman for the Yes on 522 campaign.

No on 522 raised $22 million — more money than any other initiative campaign in Washington state history — to defeat the measure, thanks to multimillion-dollar donations from out-of-state biotech giants like Monsanto and DuPont Pioneer, and food-industry stalwarts from the Grocery Manufacturers Association.

After an influx of anti-labeling campaign ads hit the airwaves, an October poll showed that support for I-522 had dropped 20 points from the previous month to 46 percent. Opposition on the other hand climbed.

The Yes on 522 camp, meanwhile, raised just under $8 million. Although thousands of individual donors from Washington state contributed to the pro-labeling camp, the majority of its financial support came from out-of-state organic and natural product companies, such as California-based Dr. Bronner's Magic Soaps, which dedicated $1.7 million to the effort.

In California, voters rejected a similar ballot measure last year. There, labeling opponents raised five times as much as supporters.

"They took a tip directly from Vladimir Lenin — that a lie told often enough becomes the truth, and they used $20 million to tell those lies," says Ron Cully, a Spokane volunteer for the Yes side. "I don't think this war is over by any stretch of the imagination."

On Tuesday, Washingtonians also handily rejected Tim Eyman's "initiative on initiatives," I-517, with 60 percent of the vote. The measure would have sent any state or local initiative with enough signatures to the ballot and make "interfering with signature gathering" illegal. Opponents argued that I-517 would infringe on the free speech rights of citizens who voice opposition to signature gatherers and the private property rights of business owners. — DEANNA PAN


Greater Spokane Inc. and the Spokane County Commissioners certainly didn't undersell their argument for voting for Proposition 1: They tied the very future of Fairchild Air Force Base to the vote, implying economic calamity if taxes weren't raised to buy a series of mobile home parks located in the Fairchild crash zone.

There was no question that the properties have for decades been in a designated crash zone — and encroached on base operations — and that concern persuaded the Airway Heights mayor and most the Spokane City Council to support removing the homes.

But the argument didn't work on the tax-averse Spokane Valley Council nor on Spokane County as a whole. Tuesday night, voters were rejecting Prop. 1 51 percent to 49 percent. As he waits for final tallies, County Commissioner Al French turns his eye to the 4 percent who turned in ballots, but didn't take a stance on the issue.

Meanwhile, local nonprofits who planned to help relocate the current residents in the parks could have been a key ally of the county, but expressed deep concerns about the project. While Habitat for Humanity's executive director supported the initiative, John Fisher, with Community Frameworks, remained neutral: "Our stance has always been that the timing was off, that new housing needed to be built before residents were placed."

French worries Fairchild remains in jeopardy:

"It means the community is exposed when we go into the next round of [base closures]. I've got to tell you I'm very nervous," French says, adding that there's no way the state or county can afford to buy the properties and relocate the residents.

"There's no other strategy we're aware of today," French says. "If there had been other resources we could have tapped, we would have done it." — DANIEL WALTERS


This year, the city of Coeur d'Alene was deeply divided over which mayoral candidate could better fix the city's divisions.

Downtown business owner Steve Widmyer and dark-horse candidate Joe Kunka argued that voting for long-time urban renewal critic and recall cheerleader Mary Souza would only pick at the scabs left after the McEuen Field fight. But Souza countered that healing Coeur d'Alene depended on voting for her, a candidate who champions public votes.

On each side, PACs lined up. The Kootenai County Reagan Republicans championed Souza, and non-partisan Balance North Idaho threw their lot in with Widmyer.

As the first vote totals trickled in, Souza was losing by 14 percentage points to Widmyer. The city council choices pushed by Souza supporters — Chris Fillios, Noel Adam and Sharon Hebert — were also losing.

In the latter days of the campaign, the groups supporting Souza began focusing less on criticizing Widmyer or Kunka, and more on firing salvos at the Coeur d'Alene Press. And a political cartoon published on Souza's site portrays a scraggly-haired ghoul labeled "THE PRESS," warning "Mary might be mayor! Run for your lives! BE VERY AFRAID."

In fact, North Idaho Pachyderm Club broke from tradition and announced they would not allow Press editor Mike Patrick to speak in front of the club about the results of the elections because the paper "has been so lopsided in favor of the Widmyer slate, it is really reprehensible and disgusting."

Widmyer, for his part, tried mostly to stay out of the fray. For a few moments, an independent Souza-bashing website called "Unfit For Mayor" popped up, but Widmyer says that, even though he didn't have anything to do with the site, he made the suggestion that it be taken down. And it was.

"I think we tried to always take the high road in the campaign and we achieved that," Widmyer says. — DANIEL WALTERS

American Original: The Life and Work of John James Audubon @ Northwest Museum of Arts & Culture

Tuesdays-Sundays, 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Continues through Sept. 19
  • or

About The Authors

Heidi Groover

Heidi Groover is a staff writer at the Inlander, where she covers city government and drug policy. On the job, she's spent time with prostitutes, "street kids," marriage equality advocates and the family of a 16-year-old organ donor...

Deanna Pan

Deanna Pan is a staff writer at the Inlander, where she covers social justice, state politics and health care. In her cover stories, she's written about mass shooting survivors, NGRI patients and honey bees...

Daniel Walters

A lifelong Spokane native, staff writer Daniel Walters is the Inlander's City Hall reporter. But he also reports on a wide swath of other topics, including business, education, real estate development, land use, and other stories throughout North Idaho and Spokane County.He's reported on deep flaws in the Washington...