Pin It
Favorite

The Magnuson Line 

Warren Magnuson's defense of Puget Sound offers inspiration as we grapple with coal trains rolling through the Inland Northwest

click to enlarge robert-herold.jpg

"Congress passes Senator Warren Magnuson's amendment banning supertankers in Puget Sound."

That was the headline on Oct. 5, 1977. Sen. Warren Magnuson had, just a day before, taken to the United States Senate floor and quietly proposed "a little amendment" to the reauthorization of his 1972 Marine Mammal Protection Act.

His amendment, which had nothing to do with marine mammals, passed without objection. Several Washington state members of the House got it through their side of Congress, and President Jimmy Carter signed the bill.

The amendment came in response to Washington's newly elected governor, Dixy Lee Ray. She was determined to open up the Puget Sound to oil supertankers, which had been banned by the Washington State Coastal Zone Management Plan required under the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972. (That plan was developed with the full support of both Magnuson, a Democrat, and Gov. Dan Evans, a Republican.)

All was going well for our new pro-energy governor until this aging, doughty Senator took the floor to propose his amendment. Ray, who once blamed Rachel Carson for malaria deaths in Third World countries, really pushed for those supertankers. A former chair of the Atomic Energy Commission, Ray wasn't known as "Dixy Radiation" for nothing — nuclear power was also high on her list. She touted nuclear energy as being "as safe as any dam" in a speech, I recall, she delivered the day before the Teton Dam in Idaho collapsed. Ray had delivered a similar speech in support of supertankers on the Puget Sound.

Magnuson wasn't buying it. The rest, as they say, is history. 

I was thinking about Magnuson's "stealth bill" (as it came to be known) the other night as I watched our third string of cheap, Chinese-made Christmas tree lights go kaput while listening to the whistle of the 110-car coal (or oil) train leaving from downtown. From here, it's over to the north Puget Sound and then — lots of it, anyway — off to China.

I had one of those "let me get this straight" moments: We put our environment at risk (remember the aquifer); we completely throw Amtrak's Empire Builder line off schedule (two to four hours is typical) during the year when Amtrak is showing its best ridership ever; we permit noise pollution throughout the downtown, night after night; and we do all this so corporate America can make big bucks while we get to buy these cheap Christmas tree lights from China?

No doubt I oversimplify — yes, jobs are at stake, for starters, in North Dakota, Wyoming and Montana. (I would note that jobs were also at stake back then, but this didn't stop Magnuson from taking the long view, environmentally speaking.)

Article I, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution delegates to the Congress the power "To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes." However, our federal system relies on state cooperation (as the health care roll-out demonstrates), even the creation of mirror agencies — they have their EPA, we have our EPA. Responsibility for railroads is shared among several bureaucracies — the Federal Railroad Administration, the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration and the Transportation Security Administration, to name the most obvious.

While states do not have the final say, they can and must weigh in. So far, I'm not seeing a Warren Magnuson on the scene, neither in Olympia nor Spokane, nor in the nation's capital. And help from Cathy McMorris Rodgers? When corporate America has a big stake? Forget it.

Economists tell us that a train of 110 rail cars is the most efficient way to move freight. Moreover, they add, trains are less likely to have an accident than are trucks; ergo, they conclude, it follows that these 110-car trains are the most efficient and no more hazardous.

But these studies fail to consider intrusion, dislocation and noise. Above all, they fail to draw a distinction between a train derailing and a truck overturning — on the risk scale, it's a bit like comparing a tsunami to a high tide. Moreover, none of these analyses consider the need for better passenger rail transportation.

Which gets us to the need for better railbeds and alternate routes around the most environmentally sensitive places. Perhaps 110-car trains should be routed around cities, not through them. (Passenger trains, of course, need to be run through cities.) And faster trains would allow more volume to be moved.

A dozen years after Magnuson's little amendment that could, his fears about an environmental disaster were made real when the Exxon Valdez spilled more than 10 million gallons of oil into Prince William Sound in Alaska. It wasn't hard to imagine what a spill like that would have done to Puget Sound. Magnuson showed us there are ways to protect ourselves from environmental disasters; what we seem to be missing today is the will to enact such protections. ♦

  • Pin It

Speaking of Comment, Coal Trains

Latest in Comment

  • Children Will Listen
  • Children Will Listen

    How art speaks to life in this particular moment
    • Jan 18, 2017
  • So Here We Are
  • So Here We Are

    Here's hoping the new president fills the office with the grace and sense of tradition it requires
    • Jan 18, 2017
  • Get Big Money Out
  • Get Big Money Out

    Letters to the Editor
    • Jan 18, 2017
  • More »

Comments

Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Today | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat
GSI’s Business After Hours

GSI’s Business After Hours @ Hotel RL by Red Lion at the Park

Thu., Jan. 26, 5-7 p.m.

All of today's events | Staff Picks

More by Robert Herold

  • So Here We Are
  • So Here We Are

    Here's hoping the new president fills the office with the grace and sense of tradition it requires
    • Jan 18, 2017
  • One Free Shave
  • One Free Shave

    Donald Trump might have merited a honeymoon with voters had he managed his transition better
    • Dec 29, 2016
  • Migrant Industries
  • Migrant Industries

    John F. Kennedy predicted our current battles all the way back in 1954
    • Dec 15, 2016
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • One Free Shave

    Donald Trump might have merited a honeymoon with voters had he managed his transition better
    • Dec 29, 2016
  • The Landed and the White

    How Americans followed tradition when they voted for Trump
    • Jan 12, 2017
  • More »

Top Tags in
News & Comment

Comment


Briefs


marijuana


green zone


Politics


Readers also liked…

  • To Kill the Black Snake
  • To Kill the Black Snake

    Historic all-tribes protest at Standing Rock is meant to stop the destruction of the earth for all
    • Sep 8, 2016
  • Mischiefs of Faction
  • Mischiefs of Faction

    Every four years, we reaffirm our national unity; this time feels different
    • Mar 3, 2016

© 2017 Inlander
Website powered by Foundation