Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Tale of Two Stations

Two nonprofit radio stations in Spokane are dogged by controversies.

Daniel Walters
KYRS' Angela Johnson, seen here in 2009, resigned over what she sees as heavy-handedness by manager Lupito Flores (background) [Photo: Young Kwak]
KYRS' Angela Johnson, seen here in 2009, resigned over what she sees as heavy-handedness by manager Lupito Flores (background) [Photo: Young Kwak]
KYRS' Angela Johnson, seen here in 2009, resigned over what she sees as heavy-handedness by manager Lupito Flores (background) [Photo: Young Kwak]

In his wood-paneled office at Spokane Public Radio headquarters, General Manager Dick Kunkel — a large man with a white beard — lets out a deep laugh.

“We held our heads in our hands and said, ‘My God, I can’t believe they did it again during Pledge Drive,’” Kunkel says.

Last fall, during the fundraising campaign, “it” was National Public Radio’s sudden firing of analyst Juan Williams and the public outcry that followed. (Williams had admitted that seeing Muslim garb at the airport made him nervous.) And more recently, just before Spokane Public Radio’s spring pledge drive began, a video prankster secretly recorded NPR fundraiser Ron Schiller calling the Tea Party activists “seriously racist.” The lack of context was deceptive — the full video shows Schiller was paraphrasing someone else — but Schiller resigned immediately.

While Spokane Public Radio and NPR are separate entities — the Spokane station just carries NPR’s programs — Kunkel still watched with dismay as the controversy unfolded.

Meanwhile, across town, where the independent KYRS Thin Air Community Radio station was also a few days away from launching a fundraising drive, veteran radio host Rebecca Mack waded into a controversy of her own.

For the first time in years, she invited her former radio partner from a different station, controversial ex-LAPD cop Mark Fuhrman, to make a guest appearance and provide a law-enforcement perspective on recent shootings. That day, he didn’t say anything especially controversial.

But that didn’t stop complaints. “Please tell me how having a racist former LAPD officer fits in with your mission statement?” Jim Dancingtrout asked on the KYRS Facebook Wall. “SHAME, this is not serving an underserved community in any form.” Sixteen years ago, during the O.J. Simpson trial, Fuhrman made national headlines when audiotapes surfaced of him repeatedly using racial slurs.

With that, station manager Lupito Flores sent an e-mail to program director Angela Johnson: “Having a well-known racist on doesn’t serve our mission, and it hurts our image, as the complaints have said.”

Mack protested. “I called Lupito to talk to him. He was unwilling to discuss it,” Mack says. “If that’s the deal at KYRS, I don’t want to be part of that deal.”

She resigned. Two days later, on Saturday, Angela Johnson also resigned, blaming Flores’ wide-ranging control of station decisions and discrimination based on political viewpoints.

“If you shut out [other] voices and you remain in a vacuum and that’s all you hear — that’s what we accuse Fox News of,” Johnson says.

FUNDING IN PERIL

Rebecca Mack calls it an ironic parallel: A few hours after turning in her resignation letter, she volunteered at a PBS pledge drive, where pledge callers complained about that NPR guy calling the Tea Party racist.

For both Spokane Public Radio and KYRS, the controversies could imperil funding. It’s too soon to know if KYRS will be affected, but Lupito says 75 to 80 percent of its budget comes from membership donations.

At Spokane Public Radio, where half the budget comes from pledge donations, Kunkel says some listeners dropped their pledges in protest of Williams’ firing. Kunkel complained to the NPR headquarters.

“Wait until his contract expired. Don’t do a public-disgrace kind of firing,” Kunkel says. “What were you thinking? Why shoot yourself and all the stations around the country who are doing pledge drives right now?”

But despite that, in 2010, Kunkel says, membership revenue actually increased 9 percent. Membership revenue at both KYRS and Spokane Public Radio has steadily increased in the face of recession. In fact, the only phone calls that Kunkel has received mentioning the Schiller recording have been from listeners signing up for memberships or renewing their pledges.

“I think it’s because [there’s] such an intense campaign to cut funding of NPR,” Kunkel says. That’s the bigger risk — accusations of bias give those who want to cut federal funding ammunition. Very little federal funding goes directly to NPR. Instead, it goes to the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, which funds local stations like Spokane Public Radio, which, in turn, can choose to buy NPR programs like “Talk of the Nation.”

In February, the House of Representatives voted to eliminate funding for NPR and the CPB. On Friday, Senate Republicans introduced a similar bill — though one unlikely to get past Democrats.

And if it passed? “Some stations in Seattle, KEOU, they’ll just brush it away like a gnat on their nose,” Kunkel speculates. Other small rural stations, however, where federal funding is half their budget, would be devastated, he says. Spokane Public Radio — which gets about 10 percent of its funds from CPB — falls somewhere in between. It would have to adapt.

“We don’t have fat to cut. First of all, people aren’t paid very well here,” Kunkel says. “We’re paid about as well as this building looks.” Located above the Vintage Rabbit Antique Mall, 30-year-old carpets stretch across the creaky SPR offices. In one room, a serving tray functions as an impromptu rain catcher for the leaky roof.

The station’s budget pays for 19 full-time staff members and nine part-time staff members (they’re assisted by over 300 volunteers) and funds three radio streams — original-station KPBX (91.1), news-centered KSFC (91.9), and new “REMIX radio” at KPBZ (90.3).

“We’d have to get rid of a lot of people — or programs — to make up $250,000,” Kunkel says.

THE MISSION STATEMENTS

The national controversies at NPR and the local crises at KYRS center around a common question: Were their respective missions violated?

Spokane Public Radio’s Kunkel points to the station’s mission above his desk. One of the key tenets: “We trust the ability of our listeners to discern between competing ideas.”

“I think it is very important that people feel we’re being fair,” Kunkel says. Since 1970, he says, National Public Radio has repeatedly been accused of a left-leaning bias — that’s why these controversies can damage the brand. It’s why Kunkel won’t play Democracy Now. Despite the number of Spokane Public Radio employees who love the program, he says it’s a left-leaning opinion program, framed as news.

“Back in the early days, public radio was pretty hardcore liberal. It was put together by 1960s activists,” Kunkel says. “But now it’s a real voice of record. It really does look at broad perspectives.”

KYRS, meanwhile, plays Democracy Now every weekday at 8 am. KYRS looks for a specific perspective. One iteration of the its mission statement begins: “Thin Air Community Radio serves the Spokane area with progressive perspectives.”

That’s one area of Johnson’s frustration. She’s not sure what “progressive” means, and she says Flores is the only one allowed to define it. “I feel that KYRS has become an exclusive station serving a specific demographic and is not serving the Spokane community as it claims to,” Johnson says in an e-mail.

Flores says he didn’t want Mack to give a platform to someone like Fuhrman. “Rebecca [Mack] didn’t like the opportunity of being on a station that had this specific of a mission, that supports progressive values,” Flores says. “That’s unfortunate, but we have to stick to the mission.”

Johnson says she hopes people won’t stop supporting KYRS with fundraising drives this week. She just hopes her resignation is a catalyst for change. On Monday, Flores sent program hosts an e-mail titled “moving forward,” asking them not to make internal personnel issues public, announcing interviews for a new program director and expressing optimism about the future.

Both KYRS and Spokane Public Radio have big plans: In the next few years, Spokane Public Radio plans to renovate and move into a building downtown near Pacific Avenue and State Street. KYRS plans to activate a newer, stronger, transmitter in August.

But to do that, both stations will need substantial support from their listeners.

Also in News

Local Limits

What stands between your shopping cart and local farmers

Heidi Groover |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Feds Come Knocking

The feds scare a medical pot store from opening up; plus, how to help those displaced by last week’s fire

Heidi Groover, Deanna Pan |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Rats Giggle Too

And that's a bigger deal than you might think

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

There's Not Enough Poverty In Kids' Books

A Whitworth researcher studies how picture books reflect the reality of American poverty

Deanna Pan |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

We Can Turn DNA into Music

An Eastern Washington University professor creates audio interpretations of living things

Seth Sommerfeld |
Wednesday, May 15,2013

Also By Daniel Walters

Abominable Evidence

Even Idaho’s Sasquatch-believer professor doesn’t buy the latest yeti hype out of Russia

Daniel Walters |
Tuesday, November 13,2012
News Briefs

Red Dawn

Idahoans fear communist business plans. Plus, an environmental gold star and a promotion.

Daniel Walters, Heidi Groover, Chris Stein |
Wednesday, June 29,2011
Nightlife

The Perry District

A tiny-sized village in a medium-sized city.

Daniel Walters |
Wednesday, February 22,2012

44 Percent

Obama and Romney are tied in Eastern Washington; plus, a shake-up at the Downtown Spokane Partnership

Joe O'Sullivan, Daniel Walters |
Tuesday, September 18,2012

Getting Schooled

A town hall, a plane crash anda charter school commission

Daniel Walters, Heidi Groover, Jacob Jones |
Tuesday, March 12,2013


Why should tax funds go towards public radio or tv? It should all be doner based Mar 16, 2011 | Reply to this comment

 

For the same reason that we use public funds for museums, art, higher education, roads, clean air, clean water, safe food, etc. Because it makes the lives of the citizens better. People in this country that don´t have kids still pay taxes that fund public schools. Why? Because an educated society is better for all of society.
Also, we want news outlets that are not owned/operated by corporations that control already 90% of the news content in this country. The majority of Americans claim that they trust PBS news above all other news sources (8 consecutive years and counting).
A well informed society is as important as an educated society. Why would you care? We are talking about less than .1% of the total budget. That means that you probably gave a quarter in taxes to PBS/NPR last year. Big deal.
Mar 16, 2011

 

I am really disappointed with how this article implies that Angela quit in relation to what happened with Rebecca Mack. Angela got a another job that she informed people about long ago. We knew she was leaving for quite some time. Lupito is one of the most laid back, easy going people I know. He has always been open in input. He is very hands off in the way that he manages people. Angela has a very strong personality and Lupito has always been accommodating to that in my opinion. I have generally appreciated that strength in her. And she did great work at the station. But so does Lupito. He works tirelessly WAY more than 40hrs a week. He is dedicated to this pIace. I am so sad that she felt the need to air her personal issues with him publicly when she knew it would hurt the station.

Not everyone agrees we need more "fair & balanced" media. Corporate media is full of voices like Fuhrman´s. I do not believe they need more outlets-they have more than enough. The whole idea behind KYRS is serving under served communities. And we actually do that.

Why is the left always asked to make room for these other views? Why should NPR be afraid to be labeled "left"? There isn´t even a real left in the media. Are we not allowed to have one tiny place that might give views other than the corporate mainstream views - views that we are bombarded with everywhere else all the time? Mar 16, 2011 | Reply to this comment

 

What is so wrong with wanting to be open minded and hear from all community members? a place where people are brave enough to debate an issue, where people can get information to make informed decisions? Why would anyone want to censor any voice? what do we fear that we are not willing to at least have the conversation? and where if not the community radio station can we hear these conversations? Mar 17, 2011

 

very succinct, so very well stated. keep on rockin! Mar 20, 2011

 

I;m speaking to you, KYRSvolunteer :) Mar 20, 2011

 

This story misses the mark as far as KYRS is concerned. The Inlander should do more digging.

This article makes it look like Angela resigned because of the Mark Fuhrman appearance, but that is not the case at all. She resigned to protest the way the station is managed and organized.

This was an incredibly difficult thing for her to do. She loves her job, the station, the listeners, and the programmers more than anything in the world and is deeply committed to free speech and the mission of the station. A person who loves her work that much does not resign without an overwhelming need to do so.

I suggest that anyone who comments here should identify his or herself. It might help promote a civil discussion.

Rosemary Johnson
former Program Directo
KYRS, Thin Air "Community" Radio

Mar 16, 2011 | Reply to this comment

 

Rose, thank you for your support. I know when you were fired you were silenced and never had a chance to be heard, I am hoping that now you will have that opportunity that you were previously denied.
While I do have some personnel issues my main concern is in the way in which the station is being ran, this is not a personnel issue this is a public issue because KYRS claims to be a community radio station where listeners, members, and programmers involvement is not only welcome but imperative to the mission of the station.
In the past 7 years that I have been with KYRS I have slowly seen the structure system change from one of inclusion by many to one of exclusion. There is no system in which I am allowed to air my grievances, those structures have been removed and replaced by a hierarchical system with no evaluation or accountability. I have tried on several occasions to air my views to the management but those concerns have fallen on deaf ears.
I believe that if this station is truly “listener supported and volunteer ran” that those individuals deserve to be heard and that transparency and inclusion once again become part of KYRS. I believe that the KYRS listeners are open minded enough to discern between opposing views. I believe that hate is hate and that censorship is censorship and if we refuse to hear from those we disagree with, if we refuse to have those conversations, open debate and challenge those points of view then we are living in a vacuum and are then as bad as those this station was founded to be an alternative to. How can you claim to be a community station that is inclusive if only one individual is deciding for every KYRS listener what is and is not heard based on their own personal bias?
For the record to respond to the previous post, while I do have a second part time job, I did not plan on quitting KYRS until August after the station goes full power. KYRS has never been a "job" for me, it has been my passion and a station that until recently I truly believed in. The Rebbecca Mack incident was just my breaking point. I must live my conscious and can no longer be responsible for excluding voices based on religion or political beliefs. I believe in what KYRS was founded to be and I do not believe that the community supports a community station that shrouds itself in censorship or exclusion. Either we are “listener supported community radio” or we are not? If there is no transparency then the listeners, members and community are not really part of the station. Whose radio station is it? It is Your Radio Station and I think all those who keep KYRS on the air broadcasting should be included and heard! That is what I am asking for, answers, transparency, accountability, and non-discrimination.
I still believe in peace, social, economic and environmental justice, human rights, democracy, multiculturalism, freedom of expression and social change.

in peace,
Angela Johnson
Former Program DIrecto
KYRS Thin Air Community Radio
www.kyrs.org - donate online
Spring on-air pledge drive March 21-27
Mar 17, 2011 | Reply to this comment

 

Non-profits drain our communities more than just from the federal dollars they receive - they also receive extra-ordinary financial benefits by not paying a corporate income tax and in most communities - no property tax - and often no sales tax...yet they can be a huge consumer of public resources. Just think of what communities could do with the revenue if all of the non-profits who hold millions and billions of assets paid taxes. Spokane county could balance it´s budget through the added property tax revenue. They have the option to do so. There is no federal law that says they have to give non-profits a free ride.

Non profits are the largest sector of business growth. Wealthy individuals know that they can avoid capital gains taxes by placing stock assets into a foundation or donating them and still retain the power of how the money is spent as through a donor advised fund or securing a place on the board of directors or setting up their own foundation and paying friends or relatives a salary for managing it.

Not all do-gooders are forming non-profits to "do good". Or perhaps the question is - good for who? In the case of KYRS one might suspect that the majority of all funding (your donations and tax dollars) goes directly to benefit Mr. Flores as all but one other person at the station is a volunteer. It´s a great way to be self employed.

If the station is getting federal funding is it not illegal for them to discriminate based on sex, race, religious beliefs? Didn´t the Inlander miss the major points of why Ms Johnson quit? KYRS is not a community radio station - it is Mr. Flores - and it is unclear as to whether their board of directors are failing to perform the duties assigned to them under the Washington code of conduct. Mar 22, 2011 | Reply to this comment

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close