Monday, April 28, 2014
Nearly 50 years ago, Mary Beth Tinker wore a black armband to her junior high school in Des Moines to protest the Vietnam war. The 13-year-old student was sent home and suspended from school, as was her 15-year-old brother and another friend. The case eventually made its way to the Supreme Court as Tinker v. Des Moines School District, and ended with a landmark decision in favor of the students.
Justice Abe Fortas wrote the majority opinion in the 7-2 Supreme Court decision: “It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.”
To this day, the Tinker case is an important precedent for a question that comes up in many different ways: Do kids in school have a right to free speech? And advocating for that right is Mary Beth Tinker, who remains an activist for young people’s free speech. She’s been on a national tour since last fall, and stops at Washington State University today for the annual Friel Memorial Communication Seminar at 5 pm.
Tinker’s tour is no victory lap or mere history lesson — the rise of the Internet and social media has created an entirely new realm of student speech. And it’s one that worries free speech advocates, because schools are cracking down on expression that doesn’t even happen on school grounds.
The legal precedent, based on Tinker and other cases, is that high school students do have a right to free speech, but that comes with a very big asterisk. Administrators can squash speech if it causes a “substantial disruption.” They can censor school newspapers in some instances. And private schools can follow whatever rules they like. But the biggest unknowns come with social media, where kids have been suspended punished for things they put online outside of school hours. This Atlantic story summarizes some of the issues well, and the Student Press Law Center provides a lot of other background materials and updates on current cases. (Disclaimer: I was once an intern there.)
Tinker has made more than 100 stops on the tour so far to talk about her experience and tell students why their voices matter. Tomorrow she speaks at Pullman High, then continues on to the Seattle area.