Tuesday, March 19, 2013
But wait, isn’t that a bad thing?
The SI cover jinx is a well-known phenomenon, but don’t despair just yet — it’s never been proven as exactly accurate. The remarkably thorough Wikipedia entry on the jinx notes that it is “an example of confirmation bias.”
“The most common explanation for the perceived effect is that athletes are generally featured on the cover after an outlier performance; their future performance is likely to display regression toward the mean and be less impressive by comparison. This decline in performance would then be misperceived as being related to, or even possibly caused by, the appearance on the magazine cover.”
But then it goes on to catalog dozens of “notable incidences” of the jinx, including Gonzaga player Matt Bouldin’s cover appearance in 2010, so you decide.
Sports Illustrated did a cover story about the cover jinx back in 2002, complete with a photo of a black cat, but didn’t find any evidence that bad things always happen. Snopes has investigated the similar Campbell’s Chunky Soup curse and Madden NFL video game curse, and found no causation in the superstition.
There is, however, a chilling truth beneath the superstition: Teams and players get featured when they’re at the top. And, typically, what goes up must come down.
But hopefully it will be a long while before we have to think about that. Happy Gonzaga Basketball Week!