"Hey Amazon," the Spokesman-Review
asks this morning, "Why not us?"
We can answer that. The Spokesman-Review
story — about Spokane joining the crowd of cities begging Amazon to locate its second headquarters in their city — discusses some of the reasons that Spokane would be a "long shot" pick for the tech behemoth.
But it also dedicates a big chunk of its front page to bragging about five reasons Spokane could be a great choice, including the World's Fair we held 43 years ago.
True, there are plenty of reasons why Spokane can be attractive to certain types of big companies, especially in the aerospace industry
. We have a direct rail line to Seattle. We have a low cost of living. Until recently
, we were both near nature and
near perfect. We have heart, hustle, spunk, gumption, and not one but three
Red Robin dining establishments.
But Amazon isn't just looking for a place with gorgeous views and a garbage-eating goat sculpture that actually eats garbage. It has some specific requirements
. And unless it's willing to overlook those requirements, Spokane doesn't have a chance.
Amazon wants a region with more than a million people.
This one is explicit. Even if you include Coeur d'Alene, the Combined Metropolitan Statistical Area
of our region, at just over 710,000 people, doesn't even crack three-quarters of what Amazon is asking for. If you only look at Spokane County, we're barely half a million.
Amazon wants a diverse population.
According to the census, Spokane and Spokane Valley are very white
— 85 percent white, to be exact. By contrast, the United States is only 61 percent white. If you look at Spokane Public Schools, you can see that our community is becoming more diverse
, but we're a long way from resembling the diversity of America as a whole.
Amazon wants an international airport.
Yes, we have Spokane International Airport. But despite its name, Spokane International Airport doesn't currently have any direct international flights.
"Non-stop to 16 destinations across the United States" proclaim the Spokane International Airport ads. And one of those destinations, San Diego
, is purely seasonal. Currently, we don't even have any direct flights to Canada.
Amazon wants room for 50,000 employees.
Technically, the Spokane region has more than enough land
for 50,000 new employees. But as we just reported last month, Spokane is suffering from a rental crunch
— we aren't building enough new apartments fast enough to be able to meet our current
According to an (imperfect) survey of apartment units, we actually have a lower
vacancy rate than even King County, home to booming Seattle. One major reason Amazon is looking for a second headquarters is that Seattle's housing prices have been skyrocketing.
Rents and housing prices are still a whole lot cheaper in Spokane than they are in Seattle, but we certainly aren't poised to accommodate sudden, rapid growth. Furthermore, Washington state, because of the Growth Management Act, has a lot more legal constraints on sprawl than a city in, say, Texas would have.
Amazon wants an educated workforce.
Our population isn't particularly educated, relative to many other cities. About 31 percent of people in Spokane County have a bachelor's degree or higher — about on par with the national average, and less than the state average.
Idaho's Ada County, home to Boise, by contrast? Thirty-eight percent of its workforce
has a bachelor's degree or higher. And while Spokane boosters can point to occasional tech startups
here, Boise has a much more prominent high-tech sector. The Idaho capital serves as a major location for Micron and Hewlett-Packard.
And while Spokane has multiple universities — and a promising data analytics degree program
at nearby Eastern Washington University — our university district
centered on the health care
sector, not the high-tech or programming sectors. Similarly, much of Spokane's manufacturing base is geared toward the aerospace industry, not technology.
Though we've had some recent successes, like cloud computing company 2nd Watch
, Spokane's major high-tech dreams have never truly been realized
. The high-tech industry was gutted during the recession
. One of the reasons why Spokane was slow to come back from that economic downturn? It didn't have the technology or manufacturing sectors that the Puget Sound region does
One way to measure the prevalence of tech jobs in Spokane is to look at the Occupational Employment Statistics survey.
The May 2016 survey, for example, indicated that the concentration of rehabilitation counselors in Spokane was about 4.3 times the national rate. We have a slightly higher concentration of health care support workers than the national average.
But the percent of jobs in the Computer and Mathematical Occupations industry? We only have about two-thirds the concentration of the rest of the nation.
About a decade ago, we did
get a business that civic leaders touted as a high-tech success story. It turned out to be a scam
that sent the founder to prison.
Amazon is looking at crime data.
Spokane isn't a violent city. But it continues to have one of the higher property crime
rates in the nation.
Amazon likely doesn't want to be so close to Seattle.
As the New York Times
went through the process of elimination to predict where Amazon would locate its next headquarters, it wrote, "We’re going to eliminate Portland, because it makes little sense for the company to put a second headquarters so close to Seattle."
So why would it make sense to locate in Spokane, which is just 270 miles from Seattle?
Amazon wants massive incentives from the city and state.
Washington state has been more than willing to shovel billions of dollars of tax breaks to companies like Boeing. But the state also has limitations. In Washington, it's illegal to give public money directly to public businesses. And while cities like Spokane have occasionally found ways to get around that
, most observers predict that Amazon is going to want a truly major bag of goodies from whatever city in which they relocate.
In most other communities throughout the state, port districts with special taxing authorities have been used to build specific infrastructure in order to attract major business. But tax-averse Spokane has repeatedly rejected attempts to create a port district
. It's one reason why Spokane has found itself losing out to Moses Lake, of all places, for manufacturing jobs.
None of these weaknesses, of course, have stopped Spokane from attracting some major manufacturers like Caterpillar and Katerra
. But lately, one study shows
, the Spokane-Coeur d'Alene area has lost more company headquarters than any other similarly sized region.
That includes the Red Lion Hotels corporation
, which moved its headquarters from Spokane to Denver, partly because Denver's truly international airport offered more flights to more locations.
Denver, by the way, was the city that the New York Times
thought made the most logical sense
as a site for Amazon's second headquarters. Spokane didn't even merit consideration.